Boy name help for baby 3

[namehelpplea]

We’ve found out we are having a little boy. We already have Theodore (Theo) and Isabelle (Izzy). But are struggling for a third name we can both agree on.
I love Oliver (Ollie) but we are unlikely to be able to use it (was a significant partner for my sister for nearly 10 years and not the nicest of splits). My partner likes James but I’m less keen.
Help!

Tobias (Toby) or Edward (Teddie)

We nearly nicknamed Theo but it didn’t stick. I would love it for baby 3 but worried that people would think it was odd to have a Theo and a Teddie.

Dylan
Max
Rowan
Alexander/ Alex
Sebastian
Gregory
Nathan/Nate

I think it is a bit. Teddy is a diminutive of both.

It is a bit like having and Elizabeth and a Lizzie, even if the Lizzie is short for Lisette.

What about Henry?

We do like Henry and it was on our list for our first. But what put us off in the end was nickname wise. I’m not keen on Hen, my husband isn’t a fan of Harry. I grew up with a name with no option for a nickname - think like Jane (not my name but hopefully you get the idea). For me it is important that they have an option to use their name or a shortened version.

I know I’m being difficult and this is why we are stuck.

We also already have lots of nephews so it excludes some other really lovely names unfortunately

Benjamin / Benji / Ben
Samuel / Sammy / Sam
Joseph / Joey / Joe
Daniel / Danny / Dan
Frederick / Freddie / Fred
Robert / Robbie / Rob
Bertram/ Bertie/ Bert
Nicholas / Nicky / Nick

What about Hal? I quite like it. Makes me think of Dickens and Henry VIII: "Bluff King Hal"!

I also really like Harold to be honest. Great old name.

What about
Freddie Theo Izzy
Archie Theo Izzy
Alfie Theo Izzy

Rory? Alistair? Rowan? George? Lachlan? Finley? Felix? Sebastian? Alexander?

You can’t have a Theo and a teddy

Frederick (Freddie)
Robin (Bobby)
Edmund (Eddie)
Albert (Albie/Bertie)
Wilfred (Wilfie)
Jonathan (Jonty)
Charles (Charlie)
Alexander (Sandy)
Benjamin (Benji)

I like James (Jamie)
Joseph
Benjamin
Conrad (Con)
Barnaby
Jacob

Alexander - Xander
Nathaniel - Nate
Patrick - Paddy
Rupert - Roo
Reuben - Roo
Thomas (prefer full name over the shortening)

if you like Henry I wouldn’t dismiss it just because of there not being a shortening. It’s doesn’t need one. James is the same really (well there is Jamie or Jimmy but longer sounding).

Theo, Izzy and Xander sounds good together

Theodore, Isabelle and

frederick
sebastian
henry
william
alexander
harrison
maxwell
christopher
nicholas
benjamin
zachary
montgomery
cassian
jasper
rowan
felix
oscar
orson
elliott
lawrence
vincent

Nicholas

Alistair

Dominic

Who says?

It sounds a bit like the Teddy Bears Picnic. She only needs a Rupert for a full house ...

Thomas
Albie
Reuben
Daniel
Jasper
Max
Bradley
Brett
Samuel.
Matthew
William
Rupert
David
Harry
Miles
Michael

Laurence nickname Laurie

Well you can but there’s a risk that Theodore will start being called Teddy rather than Theo at some point and then you have two Teddys.

Theo, Izzy & Eli
Theo, Izzy & Freddie
Theo, Izzy & Flynn
Theo, Izzy & Monty
Theo, Izzy & Rufus
Theo, Izzy & Gabriel

Theo, Izzy and ..

Will. William, Wilbur
Rob. Robert, Robin
Chris. Christopher, Christian
Angus.
Charley. Charles
Dave. David
Rick. Richard, Roderick
Tom. Thomas
Tim. Timothy
Ben. Benjamin
Monty. Montagu
Bertie. Bertram

Elijah, Micah, Samual, Sebastian, Horacio, Hugo, Gideon, Franklin, Jasper, Leon, Daniel, Rafferty, Ralph, Anthony, Ian, Sean, Ethan, Matteo, Emmett, Eli,