Would Elliot and Elsie/Elodie be too similar for siblings?

[BecomeFlowers]

I’m pregnant with my first child, so of course overthinking everything. Still early days so won’t know gender for a while, but getting the shortlist ready.

I’ve had my heart set on Elliot for a boy for years. However, if I have a girl I also really like other ‘El’ names, particularly Elsie and Elodie. Would these names be too similar for a brother & sister should a brother come along in the future, knowing I’d absolutely want to call him Elliot?

Lily is another current favourite, & suggestions are welcome ^^

If I didn't know you, or their ages, I'd assume they were twins.

Lovely names either way, Elsie is less similar than Elody.

I have a Miles and a Maia, it's never been a problem...

For me yes it’s too similar, though suppose you won’t know you’ll definitely have a boy. Suggestions

Ava
Isla
Chloe
Coralie
Sophia
Delilah
Daisy
Ivy
Rosa
Ottilie
Florence
Bonnie
Clara
Amelie
Isabelle
Annabelle
Clementine

too similar.

Elliott and Erin is a great combo

I love Elliot for a boy.

O think Elliot and Elsie are fine.

Other suggestions

Elliot and Willow
Elliot and Freya
Elliot and Florence

I don’t see a problem, they sound lovely.

They would be way too similar for me.

I’m considering the name Elliot for a boy, and I adore the name Elodie for a girl too. I think we’re on the same wavelength with names here!

nice name but the problem I see is when older a letter comes address to

miss E Become

if have 2 girls or even E Become and could be either child

Too similar. Both nicknamed El…

I think Elliot and Elsie are nice together. I don't think the matching "El" beginning is an issue as neither are likely to be shortened to "Ellie" which would be the main reason not to call two sisters Eleanor and Elise or similar.

Elodie/Elliott are just too close in how they sound so I'd avoid that.

Thank you for the opinions! I think I’m leaning towards them being too similar for myself, better to save them as future potentials.