Thoughts on baby name shortlist for sibling set with traditional names

[carrotsandstickz]

Interested on thoughts for these baby names. Don't yet know if boy or girl and s/he will have 2 half sisters and 1 half brother, all of whom have quite traditional names.

Jacob Alexander
Arthur Henry
Noah Edmund

Isabella Grace
Seren Elizabeth
Ariadne Helen

I like Jacob Alexander and Isabella Grace best.

I also like Elizabeth and Helen a lot.

Arthur, Henry and Edmund are good fine names.

All the others are ok.

I don't like Ariadne but the others are nice. Noah Edmund reminds me of Noel Edmunds too much though! Noah Alexander would work instead.

I like all the boys names except Edmund (would prefer Edward)
Noah Henry would be an alternative good combination

I love Isabella Grace
Would prefer Serena to Seren
Not keen on the last set of girls names

I think Isabella Grace is quite boring but I love Ariadne hazel- it’s very cool. Noah Edmund reminds me of Noel Edmunds. I like Jacob Alexander best of the boy names

I like all of your boy choices, but Jacob Alexander is my favourite combination.

How about Noah Jacob if you don't use Jacob as a first name? I understand why you are avoiding Alexander and Henry with it, to avoid a clash with the final sound/letter and the first sound/letter. However, Noah Edmund is far too close to Noel Edmunds. Noah Edward would be slightly preferable.

Isabella Grace is definitely my favourite of your girl choices.

Arthur Henry, Seren elizabeth

I like all your boy list but none of your girl list.

There are SO many girls named Isabella over the last 8 years or so (if you are looking at lists, remember to include all the different spellings, and 'Isobel' 'Bella' listings as well, to see how popular it has been).

Jacob Alexander - like but he'll be Jake
Arthur Henry - OK, popular
Noah Edmund - Noel Edmonds/Noah Redmond. Not keen on Noah

Isabella Grace - overused. Meh middle name
Seren Elizabeth - don't like Seren
Ariadne Helen - don't like Ariadne

I'd go for Jacob Henry and Helen Elizabeth

I like Ariadne Helen the best of the girls for what it's worth, but they are all good names.

Jacob alexander (but would prefer the other way around)
Seren Elizabeth (LOVE Seren)

Edmund is a family name. Arthur and Seren are both nods to Welsh heritage.

Arthur and Seren are my favourites. I don’t like Noah or Jacob (overused).

Love Jacob and Seren

I like Elizabeth, and Helen and Grace are okay, but I don't like Seren. I really don't like Ariadne. Isabella has been used so much recently, I'd not use it.

I love Seren Elizabeth and Jacob Alexander a lot

Arthur Henry and Isabella Elizabeth.

My favourites are Arthur Henry and Seren Elizabeth.

I also really like Ariadne, and it goes very well with Helen.

Seren Elizabeth is the winner!

I’d pair Arthur Edmund. Good solid name.

Arthur but with Edmund, all good boys names there to be fair!

And Isabella Grace from those girls names.

Jacob and Isabella.

Can we mix up the options?

If so, I’d have Alexander Edmund (love Alexander, and love a family middle name). But I like all your boy options.

For girls, I’d pick Helen or Elizabeth as the first name. With any of the others in the middle.

Seren Elizabeth.

Jacob Edmund (if we are allowed to move them around?).

Other Welsh names that I love are Mabli and Ffion for girls and Taran for a boy.

Jacob and Seren for me.

I have taught multiple Jacobs, Arthurs, Noahs and Isabellas (or variants thereof) in the last five years. Up to you whether that matters. I like them all, but I do think Noah is getting a bit tired old fad now.

Ariadne is a lot more out there but I like it. I prefer Serena to Seren, unless you have a cultural reason to go with Seren.

I think all your middle names are solid choices that will never go out of fashion, though I prefer Edward to Edmund (Edmund is always Narnia to me).