Help choosing between our shortlisted baby names after narrowing them down

[Xmaslover2018]

Thanks for previous help! Now cut down, thanks in advance for your help!

Lydia or Ruby

Eloise or Lydia, followed by Ruby.

I'm not so fussed on the new additions to your list, personally. Isla is ok, but ten a penny around me. Kate is a short form Catherine. I don't like it as a given name, and I'm really not keen on Katie, which seems pretty inevitable when she's small. I much, much prefer your other 3 options.

Eloise Lydia is my favourite combination of names ever!

Eloise and Kate are my faves.

Ruby and Lydia I like the least.

Isla is nice.

I don’t think Kate works so well with a C surname eg Kate Cannon.

Eloise or Lydia

I voted for Eloise or though I do like Lydia too.

There are an seagull lot of girls named Ruby and Isla around here so that would rule out both of those for me although they were popular for a reason.

They are all good names!
I voted for Lydia.

I like Eloise with your surname.

There are an seagull lot of girls ... ???

Eloise - too much of a mouthful IMO and will probably be Ellie. Use as a middle name.
Lydia - I really like it and Lydie. Will be Lyd or Lyds.
Kate - We chose this for DD1. Not short for anything and not Katie.
Isla - too overused. Top10 name for the past 14 years in the UK.
Ruby - I like it.

I don't know what the surname is other than it's 2 syllables and starts with a C (K sound), so I'll use Casey as the surname.
Eloise Casey - doesn't flow
Lydia Casey - lovely
Kate Casey - doesn't flow
Isla Casey - isle of ...
Ruby Casey - doesn't flow

Using Cullen as a surname:
Eloise Cullen - not great
Lydia Cullen - lovely
Kate Cullen - doesn't flow very well
Isla Cullen - isle of ...
Ruby Cullen - flows well.

I like Lydia and Eloise

Ruby is very 2008 - felt like very expectant parent I met said ‘we’re going with something a bit different. She’s going to be called Ruby’

Isla is a bit meh.

Love Kate, but I’d have Catherine on the birth certificate and ruthlessly correct anyone that tried to call her Katie.

Ruby and Isla are ten a penny. I like Lydia.

Eloise

I know a Kate Cannon 😂 We call her KC!