James or William (Will) Campbell: can't decide! Help with first + middle name

[BabyTimez]

Expecting a boy, last name Campbell. Big sister is Vivienne (Vivi).

Torn between two first names: James and William (Will). Love both equally and need a tiebreaker!

Middle name shortlist: Vincent, Oscar, Sebastian, Ezra, and whichever of James/William we don't use as the first name. Open to suggestions! We love classic, vintage, and timeless names with good nickname potential.

I’d love to know what nicknames, if any, your James goes by!

That’s great! I’d love to know what nicknames, if any, your James goes by!

He's James - not shortened at all. His brother is known as Will.

Agree James.

(My uncle James was called Jem.

No one has ever shortened my James’ name. He’s in his 20’s and has always gone by James.

William Campbell initials WC i.e. toilet, I wouldn’t do that.

Ha! I didn’t notice that until you pointed it out, thanks! 😂

What about James Daniel Campbell?

Daniel is a family name - my dad - so
while I’ve been exploring fun middle names that flow well, this would be a no regrets honor name!

They’re both … fine. But Vivienne is such a glorious interesting name. It seems a shame to give her brother a bit of a plain one! Can Sebastian be bumped up to first name status? Or Dominic? Orlando? (Too much?!)

I like James Daniel or James Vincent

Both James and William are great names, but I'd choose James in your case, as better with sister Vivienne, and better initials. James Daniel is great!