Naming girl help

[meltingalways]

Due to register baby next week at the moment we call her Poppy.
but Still go between Poppy and Olive.
help!!!!

Go with Poppy, much nicer.

Definitely Poppy

If you're having doubts, it would say to me that Poppy isn't the right name.
Flip a coin. If you feel disappointed with the result then you know whatever name it is, isn't right.

I prefer olive but if you prefer poppy go with that

Much prefer Olive - feels like a more substantial name. Poppy feels a bit too cutesy. Nice for a toddler, less so for a grown woman!

Call her Olive for a couple of days between yourselves and have imaginary conversations with other people about her, referring to her as Olive. Decide which sounds more natural.

Poppy is my favourite 😊 I like Olive but it seems to be quite a marmite name, plus she could end up being yet another “Liv”.

Maybe Polly.

Others .. Mary, Molly.
Red names - Scarlett, Rose, Cherry, Poppy.
Green names - Olive, Midori, Emerald.
Flower or tree names - Iris, Jasmine, Hazel, Daphne, Laurel, Lindsey, Daisy, Olive, Poppy, Fern, Myrtle,

I prefer Poppy to Olive. Which name do you thinks suits better? Use both names, one in the morning and one in the afternoon, for a few days.

Poppy! Olive becoming too common

Poppy with a classic second name..

Poppy Victoria
Poppy Eliza
Poppy Eleanor
Poppy Jane
Poppy Catherine

Poppy.

I think Poppy sounds lovely for a little girl whereas Olive is a more grown-up name

I agree with all the PP's who are suggesting that you alternate use of the two names until one of them becomes more dominant ~ my DN did this, not with two different names, but with the long and short versions of the same name (similar to Charles/Charlie) as she & her DH couldn't work out which one to put on the birth certificate . . . it soon became obvious to them that he would always be called by the shortened version so they used that.

I do know a Poppy who gets called Poopy at school.

Poppy is a lovely name!

Polly is a good shout. If you are set on Poppy or Olive, I agree with calling her Olive for a few days and see how it sits with you.

Prefer Poppy
With a classic/traditional middle name to balance out the cuteness.