Please help me narrow down my list for first baby boy

[BeChirpyMoose]

Having a boy in Feb and need help narrowing our short list down, we're at a complete impasse:
Theodore
Jacob
Nathaniel
Tobias
Nicholas
George
Finley
Robin

Middle name will be Alexander.

George or theodore

nicholas is quite unusual these days quite like it actually

Jacob - classic and Jake is nice
Tobias - like but prefer Toby
George - fine but popular

Robin - ok, R names like Roman and Reuben too popular
Nicholas - like, will be Nick, don't like Nico

Nathaniel - too long and breathy sounding, don't like Nate/Nat
Finley - too trendy, a bit wet sounding. Finn is better
Theodore - too long and whiny sounding, dislike it and it's overused

Which sounds best with your surname?
Initials - watch that they don't make a word.

I love Toby, George and Jacob

I like all the others but would probably personally avoid Nicholas (knickerless), Robin (getting popular for girls) and Theodore (will date to 2020s as it’s the name of the decade).

I like Theodore and Tobias, but they’re all lovely. Think about how they will suit your son at different ages (or not). And what the likely nicknames will be. Once he is born, choose one and don’t think about it anymore. You will then love the. And because you love him!

Nicholas or Alexander. Both lovely names.
Not keen on Tobias or Finley as Tobys and Finns and their variations are really overused where I live. Same for Theo and Jacob actually.

Lovely names OP. My favourites are Jacob (Jake), Tobias (Toby), Nicholas (Nick) and Robin. Least favourites Nathaniel and Finley.

Love Nicholas. It’s a classic that’s currently underused. Also like Tobias/Toby.

I like Jacob best. Then Nathaniel.

I like:

George Alexander
Nicholas Alexander

Jacob, Nicholas and George are my favourites. Nice list!

I like all except Tobias.
I would spell Finlay with an A not E. But im Scottish so maybe the E way is more common in other parts of the UK

Don’t like Nicholas (wet) and Tobias
all the others are great, but Jacob is my favourite.

I love Finley and like Robin.
I like Theo but not mad on the full Theodore.

What about Finbar, Fenton, Flynn?

I think the two that go best with Alexander are George and Robin.

All lovely except Finley.

I don’t like Jacob , too clunky or Robin, too wet, but love the others especially Alexander

I would choose Theodore (nn Theo or Teddy) or George don’t like others esp dislike Finley and Nathaniel