Girls name thoughts!

[MooMoo496]

We can’t decide between these three!

I'd rank them in the order you've listed them. I really like Ruby (nowhere near as popular now as it was 20 years ago), Isla is ok (but still incredibly popular). I'm not so fussed by Elsie, I find it a bit too nicknamey.

Ruby is by far my favourite.

I like Ruby best. I think Elsie will date very quickly.
Isla is nice too.

I like Ruby and Isla equally but would pick Ruby because of Isla’s current popularity.

Elsie is nice too, I just prefer the other names, as they feel a bit “stronger” somehow.

Hmmm, they’re all just popular girls names.

I like Isla the most. I don’t like Elsie at all. And I get bored with them all being hyphenated with -Rose/May/Grace.

Of the three, Ruby, but it seems to be used for pets.
Isla has been overused and Lila/Lyla/Lilah is becoming popular .
I don't like Elsie.

Agree with pp about them being very popular and usually paired with Rose/May/Grace.

Suggestions: Lucy, Ailsa or Elsa.

I have an adult DD Isla from before it was popular, and I still think it's a beautiful name.

Not a fan of Ruby.

My Nans name was Elsie and I think it's a lovely name, I know of 2 in my circle.

Love Ruby! ❤️

@BerolDryWipe , it is pretty, but 1000s of girls have been registered it each year for the past 16 years.

Split the difference between Elsie and Isla and use Elsa? Not as trendy as Ruby, Isla or Elsie and a bit more elegant sounding imo.

Elsie and Ruby both sound like 1950's barmaids. But I'm old, so names have different vibes to me than to a young mother.

Agree. Voted Isla as it is lovely but popular (may not bother you). I know lots of pets called Ruby.

Would also suggest Lucy.. or perhaps Esme. You might like Viola?