Which do you prefer?

[RA1988]

We can’t decide!

Have you asked this before?

Alice

Alice is my favourite, I also love Ava and Isla. Allie and Emmie are gorgeous but I prefer them as nn for full names (Alice / Emily etc).

Ava and Alice are my favourites. Alice could be nn Allie, best of both worlds, but I wouldn't use Allie as a stand alone name.

Isla is ok.

Emmie is cute, which is half the problem. She won't be a baby forever. Emma, Emily, Emilia or Emmeline, nn Emmie, are all nice but no adult is going to want to be 'Emmie'.

All nice names. I voted Allie, I like Emmie too. I'd probably have them as NN's but I don't think you need to. I have an Allie/Ally (nn for Alexandra) and have had compliments on herit before knowing her full name.

Isla and Ava are very/too popular around here.
Alice is OK, it's never been a favourite of mine.

They are all good names!

I voted for Alice.