Votes please

[ModernJew]

Talia or Hayley.

Totally undecided. DH is less keen on Hayley but I think he'd come around.

Talia. It might get misspelt as the Greek Thalia but it’s a beautiful, elegant name. Hayley is okay but it’s not as interesting imo and a bit late 80’s/early 90’s in style to me.

I think they are both good names.

I voted for Talia.

I vote for Talia. Hayley is dated, as pp said.

Another vote for Talia, no contest for me tbf.
Talia or even shortened to Tali is lovely.
Hayley is awful though.

Talia sounds chavvy. Hayley is 80’s. I’d try some others if you can.

I like both. I voted for Hayley, as although some might think it dated, it’s got a really modern sound that fits with the current naming trends, and sounds really refreshing yet traditional among all the Ellie’s and Evie’s.

Eek sorry bit l think Talia is a bit chavvy as a pp said. Much prefer Hayley but then it's one of my friend's names so l might be biased.

Talia
I think Hayley is dated now

How about Hallie?

Hayley or Haylee for me.
Also love Holly.

Thalia

Neither. I'd expect a Hayley to be about 60.
Natalia is nicer than Talia.

this!

Not keen on either particularly for the reasons other have mentioned.

Thalia is lovely, if that would work?

Wouldn't Thalia be pronounced the same as Talia (Tal-ee-ah)? We have an oddly spelled surname so I want people to know how to spell her first name at least!

I voted Talia but prefer the spelling Thalia - pronounced the same way. Hayley is very dated now, I'd go Hallie rather than Hayley.

I like both, but Talia is so overused. So I would choose Hayley.

As far as Talia being easy to spell, I know a Talia, Tahlia, Tahliah, Taliah, maybe some others too, but they're the most common ones.

I like Tali, Hayley sounds quite dated.

Thalia is pronounced phonetically, so you sound the “th” - “Tha-li-a”. It’s a classical Greek name.

I like Talia but not so keen on Hayley. I also like Mahlia.

What do people think about Hallie instead of Hayley? I think I prefer it, but DH isn't sure.

Much prefer Hallie .... much more modern than Hayley. Saying that, I actually love the name Thalia - so difficult choosing isn't it?

Hallie does sound more modern. I like Hayley and Hallie, depending if you prefer a more modern sounding name?

Agree! I'd vote Hallie although you can't go wrong either way.

Every time I mention Hayley, DH thinks he would prefer Holly, but neither of us really like Holly (and not cool for a December baby). Hallie feels like a half way point between the two