Isla, Elsie or Rosa?

[Art6537]

Hi there, love these 3 names but can't decide. I know Isla is on trend at the minute, we have always loved it but brothers sisters daughter is called Ida. Is this too similar?

We both also love Elsie and Rosa.

Which one do you like best?

Isla is way too similar to Ida sorry!

live Rosa, but Elsie goes best 🥰

I voted Rosa but it was very close between that and Elsie. Isla is very overdone and too close to Ida.

I wouldn't do Isla with a niece Ida, if you see them. Sorry. I would go Rosa personally.

Loads of girls' names at the moment seem to start with vowels! I like Rosa.

I love the name Isla but it is too similar to Ida unfortunately! Elsie and Rosa are both lovely ☺️ Or how about Ayla? To give a different vowel sound to Ida?

If you say Ida as Eye-da, then Isla (Eye-la) is too similar.
I don't like Elsie.

I voted Rosa. It is strong but nice as well. DS would have been Rosa if he had been a girl.

What a great name! And perfect for that situation. Isla is lovely but quite common now and too similar to cousin but tiny change makes a whole new beautiful name that is quite unique!

I like Rosa the best, that's why I voted for it.
I really like Ida, love to see if being used. I assume its being pronounced standard English way? And what do you mean by brothers sisters? Are you not related?
in any case, yes it's too similar.

Is Ivy an option?

Elsie. I love this, but check it sounds ok in your local accemt as i would hate "Ewwsy" pronounciation,

Elsie & Isla are both done to death round here. Isla is already dating.
Theyre the Julie & Joanne of this generation.

Rosa is much better from that angle, and it’s more mature & less cutesy.

I love Elsie but don't like Rosa.
I do like Rosie though.

Sorry typo, I meant my brothers daughter is called Ida 😂

Thanks for the responses so far and thank you to Moreteaandchocolate for Ayla. What a lovely name.

I know a lovely Ayla, such a pretty name.

Elsie is also done to death! Not a fan of it personally.

I like Isla but as with Elsie it’s one of those names that’s always just paired with the filler middle names of Rose/Grace/May which makes it boring.

Ayla will be forever spelt incorrectly.
People will hear it and automatically assume it is Isla.

Rosa. Isla is way overused.

Elsie isn't nice imo.

Rosa is the only one with any gravitas. Isla is so wispy and nothingy, and Elsie is cutesy/twee, plus both are super common.

How about Rosy?

Rosa 100% it's beautiful ❤️

I agree. Rosa is a strong name.

Elsie and Isla are forgettable and are mashed in with all of the Eva/Ava/Ella/Esmae/Elsa brigade.

Rosa.

Elsie is a milkmaid name.

My Daughter is called Isla, but was very nearly called Rosa or Elsie!

Personally, I would go for Rosa.

Other names we had on our list incase useful:
Violet
Essie
Iris
Eliza