Maggie, Cassie, or Lillie??

[AshGrimes]

The full names for these will be Magdalena and Cassandra, and I really like the nicknames I just cannot choose! I have a daughter already named Elizabeth that we call Lizzie. Which do you guys prefer and which goes better with Elizabeth/Lizzie?? Lizzie and Maggie or Lizzie and Cassie?

Whichever you pick, and I like both, have you considered that both names have loads of great options for shortening & your DD might choose a different one?

I’ve got a long name with options & I used 3 or 4 different ones as a kid before going back to the whole thing as an adult.

Edited to add that I’m not suggesting you should just give your DD your chosen short version as a name - long ones are much more fun!

Cassandra.

Cassie. Lizzie and Maggie a bit royal family-ish.
I like all the names.

Cassie is my favourite- it sounds fresh and friendly to me and suits all ages from kids, teens to adults.

I love Maggie, cassie reminds me of a mean girls character, very blonde flicky long haired kinda name for some reason

Cassie by a million miles.

You can hardly have Lillie if you already have Lizzie.
I prefer Cassie

Cassie

Cassie.

Maggie, to me, is hard and ugly, though Magdalena is beautiful.

Love Cassandra / Cassie

Elizabeth & Cassandra are lovely together too.

Cassie is really nice and Cassandra sounds classy. Lillie doesn’t really work with a Lizzie. Don’t particularly like Maggie. For Magdalena I would probably use Lena but find the full name a bit of a mouthful

I like the full name of Magdalena better than Cassandra but prefer Cassie to Maggie.

Lizzie and Lena sounds better to me also than Lizzie and Maggie.

Lizzie and Cassie is ok but I am not a big fan of all names ending with the same sound.

You also mention the name Lillie. Is that one of your options, too?
In that case, is Lillie the full name, or is it short for something?

Maggie is just the sweetest name! Love it!

I would assume a child called Maggie was short for Margaret, which I think is bloody awful for a lovely little baby.

I actually know a baby called Maggie (just Maggie, not sure for anything), her father is a huge Simpsons fan and he’s an utter bellend.

love the name Cassandra and Cassie

Cassie is best IMO.

Lillie is very close to Lizzie and also will be spelt Lily or Lilly all the time. So I wouldn't use it.

Magda is short for Magdalena not maggie

I voted Magdalena but Cassandra is also great. Love Cass

Cassie is more of a dog's name so I'd go for the other.

Cassia, Magdalena is too much of a mouthful and Maggie is awful

Maggie is very sweet but it's a nn for Margaret. Magdalena is usually Magda.

Other ideas might be:

Penelope / Penny
Abigail / Abbie

Cassie by a long way.

Magdalena is nice enough but I really don't like Maggie. Cassandra is beautiful and elegant.

Cassandra

Cassandra is forever associated with Only Fools and Horses.