Ella, Ivy or Sienna

[Clare2023]

We have just had our 4th baby girl. All under the age of 5…sibling names are Zara(eldest), the Olivia & Rosie.
We are between Ella, Ivy or Sienna.
Which sounds better with these names? We have a longish traditional second name.

Congratulations

I prefer Ella out of those 3 and think it goes nicely with the sibset.

Sienna is a bit too trendy for me, and Ivy a bit matchy with Rosie. Definitely Ella.

Ella - it’s quite classic if v popular

Ivy is nice but less of a classic and will date as it’s so popular now

Sienna is a bit hello Mag / naff

Love Ella! Sienna I like but I feel is getting so popular that it will date very quickly. Hate Ivy, a bit of a council estate/granny name to me.

Serena, Susannah and Saskia are nice though

Or Esther if you want a less popular alternative to Ella

All lovely names OP but they do remind me of the M&S jeans range!

I do like Ivy a lot I know its popular at the moment due to Blue Ivy but I find it a very classy timeless name.

Ivy by a long shot. I don’t like Sienna and there are a billion Ella/Elli/Ellies.

I like Ella and Ivy equally. If I had to choose I’d probably go with Ella but Ivy is very pretty as well. I don’t like the name Sienna personally.

Ivy is beautiful and timeless. Ella I find dull and Sienna unpleasant

Of the 3, Ella. Not keen on Ivy or Sienna.

Ella.
Ivy isn't timeless at all. It was popular in some circles around 1900 to 1930s then disappeared until recently. It's just fashionable at the moment.
Sienna is pronounced with a lot of emphasis on the 'na' bit round here so I wouldn't.

Sienna - lovely name

Ella is OK

Ella

Not helpful but I think they are all lovely and go well with your other names

Ella is very classic and timeless.
Ivy reminds me of an old lady sorry.
Sienna is nice but much more trendy than ella and ivy

I'm a teacher. I've heard kids call a child poison Ivy before so I would avoid that personally.

Ivy. Ella and sienna are done to death

I love Ivy.

I like Ella but maybe a bit too popular?

Sienna reminds me too much of Senna, sorry.

All are pretty popular at the moment round my way.

Ella is my favourite, then Sienna and Ivy last. Don’t love Ivy to be honest and I was put off using Ella by how popular it is.

Not Ivy. It’s not at all timeless or beautiful, and it’s a rather unpleasant plant.

Ella is a bit dull but fine. I like Sienna.

Love Ivy. Would have used it if my ds's had been girls. Nick names wouldn't put me off, Poison Ivy is a kick arse environmentalist feminist. Ivy also feeds the birds when very little else is ripe and provides a home for lots of critters.

Of the 3, I'd pick Sienna. I don't think I'd use it myself, but it's not overly popular and I like the sound of it the most.

Ivy is so popular at the moment that there are three in my son's 2-3 class at nursery (middle class area where older names are popular). And Ella is less common round here now but was super popular 5-8 years ago.

I like all three!

I love Ella and like Sienna.

Thank you ❤️