First name?

[ciaraaaa]

We can’t decide on a boys name, we know we want the middle name to be Michael Tommy.
I like Harrison, Spencer & Harvey however DH said No to all. DH likes Dominic which I’ve said no too.
we don’t want an old name eg Robert Steve Joe etc but nothing too out there such as Arlo. Thanks in advance

Spencer is lovely.

Why not Michael?

Wesley Michael Tommy
Evan Michael Tommy
Aaron Michael Tommy
Caleb Michael Tommy
Connor Michael Tommy
Elijah Michael Tommy
Elias Michael Tommy
Ethan Michael Tommy
Isaac Michael Tommy
Jesse Michael Tommy
Lucas Michael Tommy
Ryan Michael Tommy
Lewis Michael Tommy
Arthur Michael Tommy
Asher Michael Tommy
Dexter Michael Tommy
Felix Michael Tommy
Oscar Michael Tommy
Chester Michael Tommy
Jasper Michael Tommy
Reuben Michael Tommy
Roman Michael Tommy
Gabriel Michael Tommy

Just pick a name you both like. Middle names hardly ever get used. The baby will be Firstname Surname most of his life.

I think OP wants help with the first name. The middle names are Michael Tommy.
(So it will be "First Name" Michael Tommy "Surname".)

@SkaneTos , I don't doubt she is, but the focus seems to be on the middle names.
The DS will be 'Oliver Smith' in day-to-day life, so whether the first name goes with the middle names isn't that important. Unless the name they decide on is George Gunn or something that might sound a bit funny in full.

Harrison, Spencer & Harvey and Dominic don't seem to have the same sort of vibe but they don't seem miles apart.

Nathaniel and Oliver seem somewhere in the middle.

Jameson Michael Tommy
Hudson Michael Tommy
Calvin Michael Tommy
Franklin Michael Tommy
Bowden Michael Tommy

Spencer (love it) and Dominic have a similar feel to me, so I'd consider other names in that ballpark.

Sebastian, Nathaniel, Nicholas, Alexander, Benjamin, Miles, Gabriel, Elliott, Jacob, Samuel, Zachary, Daniel, William.

Chester
jackson
lewis
ethan
griffin
jesse
zachary
jensen
harley
dexter
lucas
roman
finley
axel
kai
elliott
fletcher
ellis

Franklin
Alexander
Riley
Hayden
Troy

Came to mind as your names have American vibes for me.

Jason
Lucas
William
Sebastien
Reuben
Gabriel
Zach
Theo
George
Arthur
Isaac
Finlay
Freddie

I like Spencer a lot!

Other ideas:
Wren Michael Tommy
Ryan Michael Tommy
Adrian Michael Tommy
Jasper Michael Tommy
Grant Michael Tommy
Clark Michael Tommy
Perry Michael Tommy
Lance Michael Tommy
Neil Michael Tommy
Logan Michael Tommy
Preston Michael Tommy
Hunter Michael Tommy
Jordan Michael Tommy
Mason Michael Tommy
Clay/Clayton Michael Tommy
Patrick Michael Tommy
Brayden Michael Tommy

I'd switch Tommy and Michael around

Sylvester Michael Tommy
Charles Michael Tommy
Edward Michael Tommy
Karl Michael Tommy
Oscar Michael Tommy
Leo Michael Tommy
Xavier Michael Tommy
Todd Michael Tommy

Nathan / Nathaniel
Alistair
Toby
Jacob
Laurence
Leon

If you both like Michael, maybe go for that - it’s unusual right now (as is Robert, but there are many Arlos..)

Could you possibly do Thomas instead of Tommy? It may help make things flow a bit better.

Michael Thomas is nice.

Zach Michael Thomas