Thoughts on girls list

[CharlotteJames19]

Alice
Eleanor
Edith
Mable
Nancy
Florence
Matilda
Anna
Libby
Charlotte

I really like Alice and Nancy. Anna and Eleanor are solid picks too.

Charlotte is undeniably equally classic, but I’ve always found it to be dull, and don’t like any of the potential nicknames. Edith/Mabel/Florence/Matilda are all fine, safe choices but aren’t as timeless as the others so are liable to date more. And Libby I find to be a bit insubstantial compared to the others.

I like Nancy and Mabel.

Alice - nice. Classic
Eleanor - nice. Classic
Edith - doesn't sound good to me
Mable - Mabel. Ok but a bit of a dairy cow name
Nancy - like
Florence - ubiquitous at the moment
Matilda - fine
Anna - classic but unusual. Like this.
Libby - like (but would use Elisabeth/Elizabeth)
Charlotte - dull, fuddy duddy

Alice and Charlotte without a doubt miles ahead of the others.

Alice - ok
Eleanor - nice
Edith - old fashioned
Mable - Blue Peter dog
Nancy - hate, due to Nancy boy connotations
Florence - love
Matilda - ok
Anna - nice
Libby - short for Olivia
Charlotte - love

Edith is my favourite, then Eleanor.

Nancy is dreadful.

Only use Mabel if you can spell it - it's not 'Mable'.

The rest are all nice.

Alice Edith and Matilda are my favourites.

I don't like Nancy Mabel or Libby.

You basically named my family!

Alice cousin. Love it
Eleanor Aunty. Popular
Edith. Great aunt. Love it and also Eadith the old English spelling.
Mable Great Aunt. Mabel is better
Nancy Aunty. Not a huge fan of the name.
Florence Like it but not the nn Flo
Matilda Love it. Tilly as a nn is fab.
Anna Cousin. Simple and classic
Libby Cousin. Love it.

Charlotte Bit dull.

I

Love Alice and Nancy.
The rest are ok.

'Mabel' is the spelling.

Also love Edith.

All lovely names.

Nancy is quite American.

Eleanor nn Nora would be my pick.

Also love Anna, Charlotte and Matilda.

Alice - nice, but don't love it
Eleanor - love (and was on our short list)
Edith - I don't hate it but don't love it either
Mable - don't like but if you do go with it I think it should be Mabel
Nancy - really don't like (DH wanted but I vetoed)
Florence - lovely
Matilda - very nice to
Anna - classic and can't go wrong. Also like Hannah
Libby - like but only as a nickname, would want a "proper" name on the birth certificate
Charlotte - classic and I really like (also on our shortlist)

My favourites from your list are Anna and Florence

They’re all fine but not my favourites.

Except Edith - I love it.

Alice - nice name, solid and classic. I know a lot of under 5s called Alice though if that bothers you.
Eleanor - okay. I know quite a few Eleanors and even more girls names Ellie.
Edith - I’m not overly keen, I think it just had a bit of a clumsy sound.
Mable - I prefer Mabel. I think it’s nice, I know one baby Mabel and that’s it.
Nancy - I think this is quite cute, only ever met one little Nancy.
Florence - it’s ok, I know a lot of them.
Matilda - popular but really nice.
Anna - nice enough, classic and sensible.
Libby - cute but a bit babyish.
Charlotte - I find this really boring. I know so many and I don’t think it has a nice sound either.

My favourites are Matilda & Nancy. I like Mabel too.

I’d go for Nancy

Alice - nice but done to death
Eleanor - very nice but done to death
Edith - I love it but done to death
Mable - Mabel. Alright but a bit twee
Nancy - really like it and not overused
Florence - too twee for me
Matilda - nice but done to death
Anna - nice, quite popular
Libby - great if short for Elizabeth
Charlotte - lovely but done to death

Flora
Serena
Elsbeth
Marianne
Adela
Zoe
Annalise

might be others

I love

Alice
Eleanor
Edith
Anna
Charlotte

I don't like the others.

Alice - I like it but couldn't get it past dh as he just kept saying 'who?'. It does seem to be having a moment but makes a lovely middle name too

Eleanor - it's nice enough but would probably be shortened to Ellie which I find a bit meh. I prefer Eleanore

Edith - cute. You might also like Meredith?

Mable - I like but spelt Mabel

Nancy - not a fan and have cone across so many recently

Florence - nice. I love Florrie

Matilda - I feel like Matilda has been done to death to be honest

Anna - lovely. I also love Hannah

Libby - not a fan

Charlotte - fine just a bit dull

Thankyou all, very helpful.
Iv narrowed my list down further.

Alice
Eleanor (but don't live Ellie)
Anna
Florence

I love your list! My favourites are Alice and Nancy. Also like Anna. Good luck in your decision!

All solid names. Well used but not ubiquitous.

Personal favourites are Alice, Mabel and Nancy. I think Alice is the least likely to date of those, so I'd pick that.

But you honestly can't go wrong with that list. All nice names

Alice - Nice but it is basically "A Lice".
Eleanor (but don't live Ellie) - I love Eleanor but dislike Ellie as well. I do love Nora though :)
Anna - Great but overused.
Florence - Beautiful, favourite off the shortened list.

Alice - like
Eleanor - ok but will be an Ellie. The 2 spellings and 2 pronunciations put me off
Edith - no
Mable - misspelling of Mabel. No
Nancy - like
Florence - ok, but prefer Flora
Matilda - ok, a bit overused, not keen on Tilly or Tilda
Anna - like, also like Hannah
Libby - not keen. Elizabeth is lovely
Charlotte - ok

I'd choose Alice or Anna. Not keen on Ellie or Flo.

Alice- nice
Eleanor- ok but can’t stand ellie
Edith- like
Mable- like spelled mabel
Nancy- like
Florence- like a lot
Matilda- love
Anna- ok
Libby- not a huge fan
Charlotte- bit dull