Which name would you choose?

[Gillyyy]

Kitty or Cicely

Kitty wouldn’t be short for Catherine/Katherine, just as a stand-alone name like Lady Kitty Spencer.

Cicely pronounced Siss-ell-ee not Sess-ell-ee. I’m not sure if people would want to spell it Sicily or if I’m overthinking things!

Thank you in advance :)

Kitty

I like Cicely (which will always remind me of Katy in What Katy Did's best friend), but I think people will assume it's Cecily, if that's likely to annoy you. (And I think people assuming she's called after a Meditarranean island would irritate me.)

Kitty is good. No need for Katherine, IMO -- it's a standalone feisty old lady name where I'm from, and all the better for it.

Kitty definitely. Really don’t like Cicely. Sounds like someone with a stutter saying silly.

I love both cicely as in the herb and Cecily or Cecile.

Kitty is fine. I know lots of Katherines,Catherines, Kathryns who go by Cat. So Kitty is fine.

Neither

As pp have said, Kitty is cute for a child but doesn’t sound right for an adult.

I like Cicely and immediately think of the herb. I also like Cecilia.

Cicely is nice, although I prefer Cecily - it’s punchier.

Kitty only as a nn for Katherine or Christina.. it’s too like Kitten for a grown woman, except as a pet (kitten) name - Kat or Kit is nice mind you.

Cicely is nice, though I do like Cecily better.

Kitty is sweet as a diminutive for a small child, but not on an adult.

I love Cicely Mary together. It is so lovely.
It is my favourite of the two.

Kitty is well known enough to suit a grown woman, especially when teamed with a classic second name. ie Kitty Elizabeth.

Both names remind me of the 1920s They are of the same ilk as Miss Phryne Fisher, Grace Kelly, Sibyl and Joan.

I really love Cecilia as another option. I prefer Kitty to Cicely, Catherine/Katarina are both lovely names for a nn Kitty.

Kitty, purely for the reason I wouldn’t want to spend my life spelling out Cicely.

Naming someone Kitty is no difference to the current trend for the name Teddy, and actually is far nicer.

I like Kitty better. They are both fine though

i think there will be much confusion with cicely. Both being called Cecily and spelt sicily. If I heard the name I’d probably presume it was spelt like the country because of the trend to name babies after places.

Cicely is lovely. Unusual but lovely. I really like it

I like Kitty as a shortening for Katherine or Kathleen but not on its own. Too twee

Cicely is beautiful! Really like Cicely Mary.

Kitty is a sweet nickname for a lot of nice options such as Katherine or Catriona but I don't like it as standalone. I think there's too much scope for it really not to suit the bearer and for her to hate it.

Kathleen is nice too

Ciceley is lovely. Really unusual, although it was more popular in the past. Ciceley Saunders is a good role model too.

Whoops - I've added an extra e. Same applies to Cicely.

Cicely. Kitty is a nick name.