Heidi or Sienna?

[Indecisivemamabear]

out of these two which would you pick and why please? Thanks!

Heidi would be the preference, it's less 'Hollyoaks'

Heidi-a bit more unique. Sounds prettier.

I always think of Heidi as a dogs name

I absolutely love sienna though!

Both lovely names but Sienna has the edge.

I prefer Sienna, it has a lovely sound.

Sienna is lovely, Heidi seems a bit old fashioned and fusty next to it.

I prefer Heidi, it has a nice sound to it and looks nice written down. Sienna has never grabbed me I'm not sure why.

Oh, have discounted Maeve? Heidi every time. Sienna is tacky.

Heidi

Both nice but Heidi more timeless. Pretty.

Heidi. A lovely classic name.

Heidi.
Sienna is a bit footballers' wives.

Heidi, only because I’m bored of Sienna, I know loads of them.

I don’t get the comments about Sienna. Surely it’s a name that spans all classes? It was in the list of top Telegraph names recently and is the name of Princess Beatrice’s daughter. There are plenty of well-to-do Siennas out there.

Sienna.

Heidi is horribly twee.

Heidi every time. Sienna is a bit naff imho.

Heidi.

Heidi. Sienna is a shade of brown. But also, more 'Hollyoaks' as someone euphemistically said.

Heidi is nice, not overly used and kinda classic. Sienna is a bit too wannabe unique and modern, will probably be very dated in just 10 years

Heidi for sure. Lovely natural connotations to me. Very pretty.

Sienna reminds me of a footballers wife.

Sienna

Sienna, definitely. It's classic and beautiful.

To me, Heidi will always be a twee girl who lives up a mountain and hangs around with goats.

Heidi

I prefer Heidi. I'm not a fan of Sienna at all

Heidi by a mile