Help! Need to decide middle name for a baby girl. .

[Samzzz]

We've decided to name our December baby Winter if we have a girl. I know it won't be to everyone's taste but we love it.
We are now stuck deciding a middle name. One of the names will be Gill, in honour of my Nan. Our top choices are:

Winter Alice Gill
Winter Isla Gill
Winter Lila Gill
Winter Bella Gill
Winter Victoria Gill

Opinions appreciated and suggestions welcome, thank you :)

I like Winter Alice Gill or Winter Victoria Gill. I think Winter is a nice name. Congratulations OP!

Alice or Victoria, the others have to much of a L sound with Gill

I would say Winter Alice Gill. Alice is a lovely middle name and sounds nice with Winter. I know a sweet little girl named Winter who weirdly was born in summer!

Just winter Gill
no need for an extra name especially not a filler one like the ones on your list

Its a lovely name, I think Alice or Victoria go best with Winter and Gill,

Winter Isla Gill

Definitely not Winter Gill, I think that looks a bit odd as two nouns (in another context), I think you need an obvious girl name in there too. Winter Gillian would be ok (just not particularly pretty).

Other ideas

Winter Bianca Gill
Winter Susannah Gill
Winter Elodie Gill
Winter Florence Gill
Winter Verity Gill

Not the first two. Her initials would be WAG or WIG.
FWIW- I don't have a middle name.

Winter Alice. Other ideas that could also work.

Winter Grace
Winter Florence
Winter Elise
Winter Louise
Winter Marie
Winter Jasmine (Although some would probably say it sounds like a scented candle.
Winter Celeste

I'd also say Winter Belle works better than Winter Bella.

Winter Holly (Nod to Christmas with her being due in December)
Winter Ivy (See Holly)
Winter Isabelle

I love Winter as a name! From your list I love Alice the most but I'd want to avoid the initials WAG so perhaps Winter Gill Alice would work better.
Another suggestion, Winter Holly Gill.
Holly is such a pretty winter plant.

Cross posted with Baby Spider!

Winter Alice Gill sounds best to me. I also like Winter Rose Gill, Winter Daisy Gill and Winter Charlotte Gill.

Winter is a pretty name.

Just Winter Gill sounds good or Winter Gillian? If you want just Gill and another middle name how about:
Winter Gill Caroline
Winter Gill Annalise
Winter Gill Madeleine
Winter Gill Felicity

Thank you for suggestions. Can't use Gillian as it rhymes with surname :(

I have a niece called winter! Such a lovely name! What about: Winter Crystal Gill?

Ahhh definitely winter Alice that’s beautiful. Other suggestions

winter annabelle
winter juliet
winter harriet
winter elizabeth
winter beatrix
winter emmeline
winter madeline
winter dorothy
winter amelie
winter josephine
winter florence

Winter Alice and Winter Isla are lovely but the initials are WAG and WIG.

Not keen on the next two ar all - they don't flow, and Winter Bella sounds like a kind of mushroom imo.

Winter Victoria is lovely.

Gill is a second middle name so it will we WAG(surname).

I think Winter Alice Gill sounds the best. Or Winter Gill Victoria?

Alice, the ‘uh’ ending of the others is too repetitive with Winter.

Winter Alice or Winter Isla :)

There is a need - the baby needs a conventional name she can adopt if she doesn't like winter (no offence OP)

Winter Lila Gill is my favourite but they are all lovely.

I read Gill as a surname Winter Jill looks more feminine
Winter Alice sounds like Winter Palace

Gill is a second middle name and it's spelt Gill, short for Gillian but can't use Gillian as rhymes with surname.