Which name is best?

[ILRN]

Arthur nn Archie
or
Oscar nn Ozzy

Siblings are
Jackson nn Jack
Lucille nn Lucy
Benjamin nn Benny/Benji

I think Oscar is lovely and suits your sibset, but then I was never keen on Arthur.
Yes, definitely Oscar.

Oscar

I know archie can be a nickname for Arthur but its not an obvious one because Archie is a normal name on its own, I have a name like that and honestly it is the most annoyng thing, so I would not do that to a child.

Arthur is surely Art /Arty?

Archie is a nickname for Archibald. Artie or Art is a more appropriate nickname for Arthur.

I've never heard of Archie as a nickname for Arthur? Why not just call him Archie? I prefer Oscar.

Oscar. I find Arthur stuffy (it’s my DS’ middle name though 😄)

If DD had been a boy she would have been Oscar or Otis 😍

Archie doesn't seem a nn for Arthur.

I don't really understand the need for a nn.

Archibald -> Archie
Arthur -> Arthie or Artie

I'm not keen on Ozzie at all, sorry.

Otis is lovely!

Why do you need a NN?

I like Oscar, but Ozzy makes me think of Osbourne...

Arthur is naff, and Archie as a NN is even worse.

I prefer Arthur, Oscar sounds too posh for me haha

Oscar is great, not keen on ozzy. If you like Archie and would use it as his day to day name, just name him that - I think it works as a standalone name, like Harry or Charlie. Artie is the obvious nickname for Arthur, Archie is a completely different name, it just shares the first two letters.

Ozzie reminds me of Ozzie Osbourne. I don't like it at all actually.

I agree if you love the name Archie and plan to use it I would just pick that as it is a stand-alone name. I love it by the way! Great choice

i prefer Archie to Oscar

I hope no one ever calls my Oscar ozzy 😅😅

Because you want to use Archie as a diminutive I'll say Oscar.

I prefer Arthur to Oscar, but I can't bear the name Archie. It's not a usual diminutive for Arthur, anyway.

I don’t like Ozzie at all, and Archie doesn’t work for Arthur imo. I vote for Archie, no nn needed.

I like both but agree with others that Archie is a not a nn for Arthur!

I really don't understand this obsession with nicknames?

Pick a name you love, see what develops organically? That is how you get a nickname.

Arthur nn Artie (favourite)
Or Archibald nn Archie

Not Ozzy

How is Arthur naff??

You might not like it but it’s a standard classic name.

I would prefer Arthur:-)