Sibling name help please!

[wildflower200]

Hello! We are expecting a baby girl in September and have managed to narrow down our name list to the following:

Oona (we prefer it spelled like this vs Oonagh/Una)
Ophelia
Audrey
Claudia
Isla (wonder if this is too common? Commonality didn’t really bother me with the boys names but is something I wanted to avoid with the girls for some reason!)
Clara (think I prefer this as a middle name maybe but not certain. I love the nutcracker connection)
Eloise

We already have an Arabella, George, Charles and Aurora.

I’m unsure about Audrey as we’d have three with the same initials but I suppose if we’ve already got 2, will it matter?

My favourites are Oona and Ophelia as I love the letter O

wow, baby number 5 - congratulations!

I really like Oona. I also like Isla and Claudia.

Ophelia goes well with your other children's names but I'm not keen on it at all - a bit of a mouthful. I also find Eloise a bit of a mouthful for some reason.

Clara is a pretty name but I don't like it and I'm not sure why! I really like Cara though.

I think Audrey seems a bit 'plain' compared to your other daughter's names.

If you like O names -
Ottilie
Orla
Octavia
Olive/Olivia

Love Ophelia.

it's fine for you to broke the trend, you don't need to pick another A name.
I like Claudia, Clara & Eloise
Maybe Eloise Clara?
Arabella, George, Charles, Aurora &
Louise
Emmeline
Eleanor
Winifred
Phoebe
Beatrice
Christina
Cecily
Alena
Anya
Anastasia
Helena
Sabrina

My favourite on your list is Eloise but I think Ophelia goes best with your children's names (agree with a PP that Octavia would be even better).

I'm not sure I'd automatically pronounce oona correctly. Although I'm Irish so una/Oonagh would be what I'm used to and probably because of that I'd pronounce your version oh-nah as I've never seen it before.

For O names I always thought Olive was nice. Ottie, and Ophelia too.

I like Ophelia but I think it very much depends on your surname. It sounds like “a feel of your” so if you have a surname that is a noun or can sound anywhere close to suggestive I would stay well clear.

I really don’t like Oona at all, whatever the spelling. It sounds ridiculous.

I like Claudia best from your list.

Oona - I know a baby Oona. This spelling. I really like it

Ophelia - not a fan

Audrey - pretty but not my favourite

Claudia - pretty and uncommon

Isla - I find it very meh as they are everywhere

Clara - I like it, but I think it's just about to explode in popularity

Eloise - not a fan

Claudia or Clara by miles.

I'd choose Eloise from your list. Your boys have very traditional, sturdy names whereas your girls' names are much more frilly. I'd look for a name that didn't end with an 'uh' or 'ee' sound, hence my preference.

Oona is wonderful, and agree best spelling
Claudia very elegant and strong

Clara is pretty but quite slight
Audrey is Ok

Ophelia is too tragic - Octavia or Odessa?
Isla is way overused
Eloise one of a zillion El names

Adela, Cassia, Iona, Estella, Aphra, Ida, Astra might be others

I love Clara, Claudia and Eloise

Clara reminds me of the nutcraker too and its a lovely name, I knew one Eloise at school and everyone thought it was very cool when we worked out you could write her name upside down in a calculator 351073

Eloise or Clara esp with your others

No offence, but Oona seems a bit... clunky. If you like the letter O how about Olive, or Orchid, or Orla.

P.S Claudia is my favourite. Good choices! Also your girls' names seem to be rather feminine, so what about Olivia. It can be shortened to Via, Liv, or Ollie.