Please tell me....

[Rainbowbaby13]

What you think of these names or suggest some others if you hate them all

Melody
Heidi
Faye
Poppy

Thank you

heidi is nice, not so keen on the others.

Melody -no
Heidi -ok
Faye- no
Poppy -like

I’m not keen on Melody - I find it a bit twee but the others are lovely. Poppy is my favourite but also the most popular in my area, followed by Heidi, then Faye.

Heidi - I like it.

I like them all. I don’t think Faye works with a one syllable surname though. Is that an issue

My order of preference

Heidi - great name
Melody - nice name if a little twee
Poppy - like it but overused in past 20 years
Faye - not keen, bit wet sounding to my ears

I really don't like Melody, not sure why - a bit twee maybe? I find Poppy and Heidi too cutesy, can't imagine a grown woman with those names. I actually like Faye / Fay. Other suggestions -

Fern
Phoebe
Felicity
Verity
Hazel
Penelope
Willow

Melody or Heidi!

I'm not fan of any of those

I love Melody. It's a name I had on my list if we had a girl.

Not a big fan of Heidi.

Poppy is cute but quite overused.

Faye is nice.

I like all of them, Heidi and Faye the most.

I dislike all of them. Some quite strongly.

Faye is pretty, although I prefer similar but more classic May. The others are a bit cutesy sounding for my taste, sorry.

Verity, Felicity, Willow, Rose/Rosalie, Iris, Sylvie, Jessamine/Jessamy have a similar style to your other choices to me but perhaps a bit more elegant feeling imo.

Melody - 0/10 - terrible and don't like 'Mel'
Heidi - 6/10 - neither here nor there
Faye - 0/10 - boring
Poppy - 7/10 - cute and best of the lot

Melody - beautiful and original but maybe not great for a serious adult woman
Heidi - strongly dislike, way too twee
Faye - love! Beautiful and classy
Poppy - strongly dislike, sounds like describing someone who 'pops'?!

Alternatively how about Cara, Melissa, Alice, Mia?

I like Faye less than the others but they are all fine.

I like Heidi.
I really don't like Faye
Melody is interesting and ok imo.
Poppy is a dog's name

Melody - love love love ❤️
Heidi - meh
Faye - ok. A bit boring
Poppy - absolutely awful, it doesn't sound like a name. Like a sound you'd make when popping something.

If melody is twee then how about Elody?
It was my chosen name but I'm having a boy

Thanks for all the opinions

I like the suggestions of

Phoebe & Elodie

Phoebe is great.

I know an adult Heidi, and tbh, the name doesn't suit her at all.

I only like Faye and Poppy which I think are lovely.

Phoebe is nicer than of your original 4 suggestions

Elodie is nice too but I'd be worried about it getting shortened to Ella, Elle or Ellie of which there are thousands in the 0-20 age bracket

Melody - ok but wll get ding-dong jokes. I prefer it to the insipid Elodie
Heidi - fine
Faye - prefer Fay
Poppy - fine

Love Melody and Faye. Not keen on the other two.