Could I use this name?

[seasunshine22]

We already have a Daughter called Mabel would we be able to use Esmè for another girl? Don’t know if it sounds ridiculous as both names have ‘May’ in them?

I don't think I would've noticed until you pointed it out.
So I think it's fine

I wouldn't have noticed either

I wouldn’t have noticed either

Not sure it would be huge problem, though if you're not sure maybe try calling the names through your house to see if you can hear the difference. If it bothers you then it bothers you though and that's not necessarily wrong. If you plan on using an accent for Esme, then Esmé is the correct version.

Probably this is just a typing error, but the accent on the final 'e' of Esme is pointing the wrong way. It should be an acute accent - sloping upwards from left to right.

I think they go nicely together

No, a couple of lovely names!

Definitely ok

There is no 'may' sound in Esme.
But it wouldn't matter if there was anyway!

It's Esmé

I think it's ok

Esme is usually Ez-mee which works with Mabel

If you wanted the Ez-May pronunciation it’s a little close but ok I guess.

Pronounce it Ez-mee and it won't be a problem.

It's spelled Esmé

And there is no 'ay' sound. It's Es-meh.

I think it's fine. To me it's not quite the same sound. Shorter in Esmé.

It's fine. Just make sure you spell Esmé correctly. You could leave off the accent altogether. I think the two names go nicely together.

I also wouldn't have noticed

I wouldn’t have noticed because I pronounce it Ez-me. But the pronunciation you’ve chosen is no problem with Mabel imo. Lovely names.

I didn’t notice either. The names go nicely together.

Thanks everyone. I prefer the Es-May over es-me pronunciation.

Both lovely names and they "go"

Fine with me, don’t find the names similar. I like both names btw and know a young adult called Esme (pron Es May).

I wouldn't have noticed either