Help not getting any closer to deciding!

[timeisnotaline]

I’m worried baby is about to arrive and we haven’t made any progress on names. Would be interested in thoughts and combinations for middle names that might help! Our (my ) ideas, the combinations are are a bit random though:
Charlotte (Charlotte Elizabeth? Charlotte Imogen?)
Audrey Clothilde
Clementine Grace
Elodie Isabel
Marigold Audrey
Mirabel Grace
Millicent
Ida
Phoebe
Persephone

Congratulations! Out of your list I like Elodie and Audrey
How about Margot?

Charlotte Grace or
Clementine Grace

Elodie Isabel is lovely.

Marigold is awful

I love Clementine Grace.

Marigold, Persephone and Clementine aren't great to be honest. I do like the rest though

I really like Marigold personally but I think it would be too much with a middle name like Audrey that's also has an old-fashioned feel to it.
Charlotte Elizabeth could have a bit too much of a royal vibe!

Elodie Isabel

Audrey Clementine
Phoebe Mirabel
Elodie Charlotte

Mirabel!!! I love it but dh vetoed. I've never met anyone with this name!

I like Charlotte, Mirabel and Elodie.
Do you have any family names that you want to use as middle names ?

Clothilde is the family name I’d like to use as a middle name if it works. Dh has vetoed it as a first name! I hadnt thought of mirabel as a middle name, might have to try some combinations out. Charlotte Elizabeth is too royal I think as a pp says although also family names. Charlotte Clothilde was too CC though. Agh i wish I could just pick 6 names!!

Clementine or Charlotte.

Mirabel will probably be very popular now with all the Encanto love, if that bothers you

Clementine is one of my favourites

Elizabeth Imogen

Charlotte (Charlotte Elizabeth? Charlotte Imogen?)
Audrey Clothilde
Clementine Grace
Elodie Isabel
Marigold Audrey
Mirabel Grace
Millicent
Ida
Phoebe
Persephone

I think the problem with Mirabel is that it's going to explode in popularity due to Encanto. Otherwise I'd choose that.

I love Ida if pronounced the German way (Ee-dah rather than Eye-dah).

However from your list I'd go Elodie Clothhilde (because you said that was a family name)

Charlotte is the only name I like from your list (I may be biased as I have one). I think Charlotte Grace flows really well. If it helps, mine is Charlotte Jessica.

I’d settle on a short list of first names, middle names are so rarely used don’t tie yourself up in knots about them

Persephone is lovely
Millicent has got quirky charm
Phoebe is fine

Clementine, Elodie, Audrey and Ida are all OK but so of the moment they will date
Charlotte is great but so overused

Marigold. It’s a joke ‘they called her Marigold and hoped she would’ DON’T

@JakeyRolling

I think the problem with Mirabel is that it's going to explode in popularity due to Encanto. Otherwise I'd choose that.

I love Ida if pronounced the German way (Ee-dah rather than Eye-dah).

However from your list I'd go Elodie Clothhilde (because you said that was a family name)

I didn’t realise the encanto connection until Mirabel had climbed the list considerably, I think it is a problem. Elodie Clothilde is pretty but it so french as a combination , I think that might be bordering on pretentious (elodie is not a family name).

Clementine Grace is nice.

I absolutely love Elodie but not paired with Isabel, which I also quite like just not together.

I'm not the biggest fan of Audrey but Marigold Audrey is a great combination.

I also love Millicent, Ida, Persephone, Mirabel, Phoebe and Charlotte! How about Persephone Grace?

Charlotte Mirabel is pretty

Camilla would be nice, I find it slightly prettier than Millicent, something like Camilla Grace?

I love Charlotte & mathilde & Elodie

Matilda Elodie is nice too. If Mathilde feels too French.

I like Charlotte Elizabeth but it is pretty 'royal'. Though I wouldn't mind that.

Charlotte Clothilde is nice, (I'm not sure what's wrong with CC though)

Millicent Clementine grace Isabel are all nice.

Just personal choice, but not:

Marigold Audrey
Mirabel
Ida
Phoebe
Persephone

Love Phoebe.

Phoebe Grace is adorable.

@timeisnotaline.
If you like Mirabel but not sure about it because of the encanto connection, have you considered Mirielle?
Charlotte and Elizabeth are both timeless classics and beautifull