Brother for Tobias

[anotherlittlesquish]

Hi all!
We are due a little boy in a few weeks and struggling for a name
We already have Tobias who we mostly call Toby.

Some names we’re considering:

Sullivan (Sully)
Miles
Arthur
Reuben
Otis

Which of these do you prefer or do you have any other suggestions maybe?
Thanks!

I like Otis.Other suggestions.
Tobias and
Rex
Finley
Dexter
Hugo
Arlo

Miles - lovely and goes well with Toby

Arthur and Reuben great but way overused. I don’t personally like Otis. Sullivan I do think is a bit grim (sorry!) and if I were Sully I’d feel v annoyed my brother got a fab name with history like Tobias, and I didn’t…

Otherwise - Rufus, Nathaniel (Nat/Nate), Christopher (Kit, Christy), Nicholas (Nico), Robert (Robin), Ernest (Ernie), Edmund/Edwin (Ned), Silas, Hugh, Patrick, Alexander (Sandy, Xander), Alistair, Elijah (Eli), Joshua (Josh), Barnabas (Barney - Tobias and Barnabas known as Toby and Barney is a bit heart melting..)

I like them all apart from Otis.
Edmund (Ted)
Wilfred (Wilf)
Alfred (Alfie)

I only like Reuben and Sullivan. I like Niles but not Miles.

Other suggestions:
Cedric
Lucian nn Luc
Lucca
Morgan

Alexander
James
Conrad
David
Lucien

Jareth

Do it. Do it do it do it do it.

Love Miles Arthur and Otis
Don't like Reuben

Joshua
Samuel
Josiah

(We have a Ted and if his younger sister had been a boy, she'd have been Tobias/Toby.)

Miles is the nicest on the list, and is another classic name. They go well together

My first thoughts were Barnaby (Barney) , Nathaniel (Nate), Robert (Bertie), Alexander (Alex) or Louis.

I like Reuben and Sullivan best with Tobias although my favourite name is Otis. Other suggestions

Nathan(iel)
Gabriel
Raphael
Hugo
Jasper
Sebastian
Rupert
Rudy
Wilfred

Otis

Arthur

Tobias and Milo
Tobias and Albert
Tobias and Edmund
Tobias and Ezra
Tobias and Murphy
Tobias and Cormac
Tobias and Rupert
Tobias and Otto
Tobias and Flynn
Tobias and Theodore
Tobias and Oscar
Tobias and Felix
Tobias and Finnegan
Tobias and Hugo
Tobias and Walter
Tobias and Percy
Tobias and Jude
Tobias and Cody
Tobias and Harvey
Tobias and Solomon
Tobias and Archie
Tobias and Rory
Tobias and Jasper
Tobias and Hugh
Tobias and Gideon
Tobias and Nolan
Tobias and Asher
Tobias and Lucian
Tobias and Caspian
Tobias and Soren
Tobias and Cedric
Tobias and Callum
Tobias and Malcolm
Tobias and Colin
Tobias and Casper
Tobias and Bennett
Tobias and Fletcher
Tobias and Griffin
Tobias and Harrison
Tobias and Kieran
Tobias and Rowan

Miles and Reuben are nice.

Sully means to taint or spoil, so I'd avoid it. How about Solomon with nickname Sol or Solly?

Jasper
Julian
Francis (Frank)
Lawrence
Alexander
William
Jonathan
Richard
Charles
Andrew

Giles
Rufus
Simon
Amos
Theodore
Moses

I like Miles best from your list. I have a Toby. His brother is called Flynn If we have another we like Rowan.

I like Arthur and Reuben but they seem to be very popular at the moment!
I really don't like Sullivan and not keen on Otis.
Sebastian was my first thought from the title of your post.

I like Solomon. I know a Solly and it really suits him. Good name and nice with Toby.

I always think Tobias and Zachary go together well.

I personally don't like any of them but would choose Otis. Would you consider another biblical name to go with Tobias?