Girls names list

[DoodleBelle]

What do you think of the following girls names?

Penelope
Poppy
Imogen
Grace

I also like Felicity, Annabel, Beatrice, Harriet, Verity but DH has vetoed

Middle names we are considering:
Madeleine (love this name but hate nn Maddy)
Jemima (can't use a J name as a first name)
Primrose (current front runner but it doesn't flow well with all names)
Clementine (doesn't flow well with all names)

Which combination is your favourite/why? Any other suggestions we might like?

I like every single one!
Primrose Grace would be my choice.

Of the first names you both like, I only love Imogen - fairly classic, elegant, Shakespearean and popular but not really overused. Grace's are just everywhere (whether as a first name or as a hyphenated/middle name), Poppy is too cutesy for me and I personally don't like the strong "pee" sound in Penelope, sorry.

Imogen Jemima would be lovely - I'm not sure the repeated n's in Madeleine and Clementine flow quite as well, and I personally find Primrose a bit stuffy/dowdy sounding (although I don't suppose that matters as much for a middle name).

Shame you can't sell DH on your other first name choices - I like all of them (apart from perhaps Annabel, as I much prefer less frilly Anna). If I was just picking my "favourite names" I'd probably choose Verity Madeleine.

Penelope Madeleine. I don't love Poppy or Grace as first names and I don't love Primrose with Penelope or Poppy. Grace is a bit too popular for me.

I like Penelope. Grace is just waaaay overused as a first or middle name. I don’t like Poppy, it’s too cutsey.

Great list
I like Imogen best

I like Penelope and Imogen very much.

I don't much like Grace but don't mind it as a middle name, Poppy is much too cutesy, and I hate Primrose.

I think I'd go for Penelope Grace or Imogen Madeleine.

Of the first names I would choose Penelope, I prefer Penny as a nn than Immy which is a popular shortening for Imogen, and I dislike the other two name options. For middle names with Penelope I think Clementine or Madeleine.

Hattie Grace is quite nice

Or Clemmie Grace

Penelope - too long
Poppy - like
Imogen - nice, not keen on Immy
Grace - just OK, don't like it as a middle name

Madeleine (love this name but hate nn Maddy) - my thoughts too
Jemima (can't use a J name as a first name) - really like
Primrose (current front runner but it doesn't flow well with all names) - not keen
Clementine (doesn't flow well with all names) - don' like

I'd pick Harriet as a first name, but from your list Poppy.

Middle name would be Madeleine

Madeleine Grace would be my pick.
If you don't want Madeleine as a first name how about Grace Madeleine?
Also like Annabel Grace.

Imogen is the best but I’m biased as it’s my eldest daughters name, she’s 4.5 yrs.

Penelope Grace nn Nell

lovely!

Imogen Primrose

Penelope - yes, lovely
Poppy - no, too twee
Imogen - yes, beautiful
Grace - yes, I like it a lot

How about Penelope Grace or Imogen Grace?

I also like Madeline - as it would be a middle name, it wouldn't get shortened.

Imogen

It’s nice and just uncommon enough- your other names are top 50 names with Grace in particular I find being very common