If I like Nathaniel and Elijah...

[Allium16]

...what other boys names might I like? Still looking for that elusive name that both me and DH like...

Saul, Soloman, Isaac, Caleb, Elias, Asher, Abraham, Daniel, Noah, Samuel, Jacob, Ezra, Jonah, Joshua, Emmanuel, Jude, Jesse, Israel

Some of these won't work if have already have sons named Nathaniel and Elijah but just in case you just like those names there are some alternatives.

Rueban?
Ira?

Dominic
Gideon
Barnabas
Tobias

Josiah, Malachi, Matthias, Matthew

Caleb, Noah, Adam, Sebastian.

Jacobi
Isaiah
Simeon
Rudy
Gilbert
Heath
Jovian
Morgan
Ethaniel
Logan

Eli
Luca
Jude
Joel
Seth
Saul
Zachary
Jared
Samuel

Jeremiah

Silas
Samson
Sonny

Elias
Zachary
Isaac
Cole
Adam

Gabriel
Patrick
Jonah
Zebulon

Ezra
Isiah
Cael

Nathaniel, Elijah and Zach (or Zachary)

Alistair, Jerome/Jeremiah, Jethro, Jonas, Gideon, Patrick, Augustus, Julius, Cassian, Josiah, Hector, Lysander, Laurence, Rufus, Kester, Saul, Jude, John, Rafe, Abraham, Sampson, Xavier, Gabriel, Silas, Seth

Jesus

Open your Old Testament and work your way through it.
PPs have listed some excellent OT names on this thread.