Help... please rate!

[BridgetGetTheGin]

Please rate...

Florence
Grace
Emelia

Cannot pick. Any other suggestions welcome. Please be honest!

They're all nice. They're all quite popular which would put me off.

I like Grace best.

Love Florence.
Prefer Emilia to Emelia, but it'll get confused with Amelia.
Don't like the 'gr' sound in Grace.

@NuffSaidSam

They're all nice. They're all quite popular which would put me off.

I like Grace best.

True... any other classic sounding names?

Harriet
Genevieve
Charlotte
Penelope
Eleanor
Jemima
Alice
Alexandra
Elizabeth

Classic sounding names? (Cracks knuckles) ok what about

Georgina
Victoria
Eleanor
Marianne
Sophia
Esmeralda
Elizabeth
Katherine
Katrin
Prudence
Charlotte
Mary
Anna
Edith
Ivy
Ida
Alice
Esther
Esme
Sara
Zara
Beatrice
Margot
What sort of vibe are you going for?

LOVE these suggestions.

Really like Alice, Charlotte, Margot and Beatrice !

Beatrice is a good call if you like the sss sounds in Florence and Grace, but want something more unusual.

My 2yr old daughter is called Grace so that's the one for me. My 2nd choice is Emelia

Your choices are all lovely but quite popular at the moment. If you like Emilia you might also want to consider Julia or Celia/Cecilia instead.

And perhaps classic Rose or Eve instead of Grace? Or even Iris which is retro popular but not quite as much as your choices.

Florence is also quite retro/vintage popular as much as classic, so the same style to me would be names like Emmeline, Cora or Josephine.

Florence - 7/10
Grace - 8/10
Emelia - 6/10 prefer Amelia

Other suggestions...

Alice
Annabelle
Amelia
Arabella
Ava
Beatrice
Beatrix
Beth
Callie
Charlotte
Clementine/Clemmie
Connie
Darcie
Delilah
Edie
Effie
Ella
Elsie
Emily
Emmeline
Erin
Evangeline
Evelyn/Evie
Florence/Florrie
Freya
Georgia
Hattie
Heidi
Holly
Ida
Imogen
Isabella
Isla
Isobel
Jenima
Jessica
Kaitlin
Katie
Lana
Lilly
Lois
Lucy
Madeleine/Maddie
Maisie
Matilda/Tilly
Mavie
Milly
Megan
Molly
Nellie
Niamh
Norah
Olivia
Ophelia
Penelope
Phoebe
Primrose
Rosalie
Ruby
Sadie
Scarlett
Sophia
Thea
Violet
Willow
Wynter
Xanthe
Zadie
Zara

Grace is hard to pull off if you are clumsy!!

Florence - lovely. Popular but lovely.
Grace - apologies to parents of Graces but I find this a bit meh.
Emelia - not this spelling which is neither one nor the other. Emilia is lovely; Amelia is nice enough.
I would go for Emilia (but that spelling only) or Florence from your list but how about:
Constance
Cecily
Beatrice
Felicity
Esther
Harriet
Tess/Tessa

Florence is lovely and I'm sure it's less popular than the other two. Flo / Florrie are cute nn.

I'm really leaning to Florence... but I have a son called Freddie. Is that weird?! Florence and Freddie?

I really LOVE Grace too!

I'm stuck between Florence and Grace.

Emilia. My fab great niece is called Emilia, so I'm biased.

Grace
Emelia

Florence

DD2 is Grace so I'm obviously biased but it's a lovely name 😊.

How about:

Fern
Wren
Eden
Brooke
Robyn
Felicity

OP, your initial suggestions are great. Any of those would be fine.

I love Florence and Floss or Flossie is cute. If your DS Is Freddie, erm... It rings a bell - Though I’ve been out of the UK for a while, wasn’t Florence and Fred a clothing range in Tesco?

LOVE Grace.

Probably just me but when I think of Florence I always wonder if the parents/person has actually been there.
I also think of The Magic Roundabout

I love Florence and love the nickname Florri. I know someone whose just used Florri as a full name and I just love it.

@BridgetGetTheGin

I'm really leaning to Florence... but I have a son called Freddie. Is that weird?! Florence and Freddie?

Florence and Fred = Tesco 😬