Is this naff (family middle name)

[Changedname81]

My mum is Jane
His mum is Marion
My middle name and mum’s mum is Marie

To incorporate all - Mariane? Or is the ane ending too tenuous a link to Jane?

Lucy Mariane ?

I think that's really nice actually

I like it 🤷‍♀️ I didnt really get the jane link until you explicitly explained it at the end of your post but mariane / marianne is a nice name

If I were your mum I would feel a bit shortchanged tbh!

Lovely. You can always explain the Jane part of it to your mum!

Or, how about Marjolaine?

@Naggety

If I were your mum I would feel a bit shortchanged tbh!

Not if it’s Lucy Mariane.

I wouldn't have got the jane connection. I prefer Marianne spelling. Think it's a lovely name.

Marjan is the Dutch version of Marianne. Could work?

I'd go with Marianne personally.

I don’t see the amalgamation. Its a pretty combination but think it’s a bit of a stretch to say the ending comes from Jane.

I would go with Marianne but I do think it’s a lovely name 😊

I think it's pretty but also doesn't really include Jane. But if her middle name is Marie then surely it's still a connection to use Marianne. Marion/Maria/Marianne all similar.

I don’t think you need to make the Jane connection at all as it’s so similar to Marie so carrying that on really. It’s a lovely name with a great associated song, I really like the combination you’ve chosen

Mariane is pretty and unusual , lovely

Not if it’s Lucy Mariane.
Yes because, as you can see here, literally nobody makes the connection unless it is explained to them. OP - you could always just use both names : Marion Jane. They are both nice.

I wouldn’t go for an unusual spelling for a first name but as a middle name I actually really like that! Lovely idea.

If you want to name a baby after someone then use the actual name , if not I wouldn’t bother . Marianne is a pleasant enough name though .

I like Marianne but it’s a combination of Mary and Anne

Why not just use Marian Jane?

It's naff.
Is Mariane a name.
Lucy Marie is nice. Lucy Marianne is nice. Lucy Marion is OK. Lucy Jane is a bit 1960s.

I like it.

If you want to get more of "Jane" in, Marjane is also a name. Or Mary-Jane.

I think it is naff

It's nice enough as a name but nobody is going to get Jane from that! Could you do two middle names? My kids all have two and so do I because it's a family thing on my side.

I think its pretty, but I also wouldn't notice the "ane" from Jane, because it would be pronounced differently.

Lucy Mary-Jane? Or Lucy Jane-Marie?