Poppy and Reubens sibling is called...

[Missmonkeypenny]

I am very unexpectedly pregnant with DC3 and my mind is somewhat blank on the name front, having thought we were done at 2! Please help

Other names we liked for previous DC were :
Edith
Ada
Margot
Annie

Ezra
Eli
Abel
Jude

Stella

I love Edith, Margot and Annie. Another possibility is Rose...as a first name it's quite uncommon but so pretty.

From your boys list I find them all a bit too Biblical really.

For boys I like Albie and Tommy (Thomas) and Edward.

Eliza
Colette
Lois
Thea
Nancy
Zara
Elsie

Isaac
Seth
Miles
Noah
Jesse
Caleb
Toby

Poppy, Reuben and...
Anneli
Saskia
Sadie
Ada
I do like Edith too though
and
Isaac
Freddie
Jack
Leon

Poppy, Reuben and Matilda
Poppy, Reuben and Joel
Poppy Reuben and Titus
Poppy Reuben and Eliza
Poppy Reuben and Junia

I love the name Abel so I definitely vote for that for a boy. For a girl I quite like Lydia or Autumn with your other names for some reason.

Poppy and Reuben are v different types names! So feels like might be good to go for something v different again - Edith or Margot both nice, or maybe something like Casper if it’s boy

Jude for a boy
Joy for a girl

I always liked Esme

Poppy Reuben and Edith sound lovely together. Your boy's names are biblical like Reuben and would make Poppy the odd one out.
How about something like
Wilbur
Oscar
Marcus
Jasper

Isobel or Jacob

Poppy Reuben & Louis
Poppy Reuben & Jake
Poppy Reuben & Joseph

Poppy Reuben & Lilly
Poppy Reuben & Maeve
Poppy Reuben & Nina

@TheVanguardSix

Jude for a boy Joy for a girl

Outing but DS and DDs middle names

@Hufflepuffsunite

I love the name Abel so I definitely vote for that for a boy. For a girl I quite like Lydia or Autumn with your other names for some reason.

Cannot use Abel due to our surname. It sounds as though you're describing someone EG he was an Abel Fisher

Alexander
Joshua
Jacob

Amelie
Sophia
Harriet

Poppy, Reuben and:

Amelia
Olive
Annabel
Francesca
Juliet
Genevieve

Sebastian
Tobias
Elias
Luca
Jasper

Lucinda
Lucille
Bethany

Jonah
Patrick
Callan

Jude for a boy. Joy for a girl. Outing but DS and DDs middle names.

Oh my heavens, OP! What are the odds!
Back to the drawing board!

Ezra (from your list)
Saul
Wyatt
Aidan

Ada (from your list)
Cleo
Darcey
Sybil

If your first two have J middle names what about Titus Joel for a boy and Sarah Junia for a girl?

Hazel
Cora
Marnie
Leona
Effie

Felix
Orson
Toby
Noah

Joy.

Well that’s what sprung to mind.

Poppy Rueben and
Oliver
Jacob
Noah
James

Alice
Sofia
Olivia

Georgia.
But only because I happen to actually know a very lovely set of siblings with these names!

Sigmund

Emily
Sylvia
Charlotte
Sebastian
Nathaniel
Rupert