Sienna or Sophia?

[emmie841]

Which do you prefer?

I like both, but they do have different vibes. I’d probably go for Sophia, but it’s close.

They were my two choices as well!
We went Sofia but if I'd had another girl it would definitely been Sienna.
Love both!

Sophia all the way

Sophia

Sophia

Sophia

Sienna, less dull of the two.

I’d choose Sienna, it’s a very pretty name. Sophia/Sofia is sooo overused in my area (although may be less so where you’re from), it feels less appealing to me.

Sienna 100%. Sophia and Sophie all end up getting called Soph anyway

My daughter is a 'Siena'.

I think I prefer Sophie to Sophia

But both are nice

Sophia is classic. Sienna is lovely but I feel it will date.

I love both.

Sophia is very common

Sienna

Sophia (while very popular) feels much more classic to me - it's an elegant name with a Regency or European feel imo, so would be my choice of the two.

Sienna is a celeb led name, so feels a little bit tacky to me - it shot up in popularity in 2005 (from rarely used, to the top 100) when Sienna Miller became famous the year before.

Sophia is classic. Sienna will date badly.

Ooooh I like them about equally, but I think Sophia is more timeless. So I think Sophia, by a whisker.

Sophia by a mile for me.

Sienna definitely, Sophia/Sophie is so overused

Definitely Sophia - it's classic, works in lots of languages and has a lovely meaning. I don't like place names and Sienna is a bit too trendy.

I don’t love either, but much prefer Siena (and definitely with one N!)

Sienna. There are about six Sophias (or Sophies) in every year group at my kids’ school. And I know two baby Sophias born last year.

It’s lovely but sooooo overused.

We had Sienna as a middle name for our little girl. Sophie was supposed to be her first name, but once she was born, it wasn't the right name for her.