Girls names help

[Cocomelons]

Hi,
Really struggling with settling on a girls name for DD2. DD1 is an Isla. Surname is fairly long. We have the below list. What are your opinions on them?

Sienna
Halle
Phoebe
Darcie
Isabelle
Polly
Marnie

Thanks

Love sienna
Darcie would be my next choice

Isla and Sienna is my favourite pair. Isla and Phoebe is nice too. Don't really like the others.

Sienna - I don't like this much
Halle - not keen. I'd spell it Hallie if you were going to use it though.
Phoebe - don't like at all
Darcie - really don't like at all
Isabelle - ok. A bit boring. A bit weird with Isla
Polly - gorgeous gorgeous gorgeous
Marnie - really dislike

Isla and Polly is definitely the coolest pair.

Marnie or Phoebe get my vote.

Polly, Marnie or Phoebe

Actually really like Darcey and Sienna too! Isla and Sienna maybe sound best

Sienna - love
Halle - like this name but would spell it as hallie
Phoebe - love
Darcie - dislike
Isabelle - not keen
Polly - ok
Marnie - I didn't previously like this but the more times I see it the more I like it

Marnie is my favourite by a mile and sounds amazing with Isla

Polly is very cool.

I quite like Marnie too 🙂

Phoebe or Marnie

Polly is the one I'd choose.

Thanks everyone. Your opinions have been helpful 😊

Really like Polly!

Love Polly

Love Isabel too, or Isobel if you are building a Scottish theme. Find the French spelling a bit flouncy.

Phoebe is nice

Not keen on the rest.

None of them are my taste apart from pretty Isabel (if spelt this classic way - I prefer more traditional names in general eg. I only like Marnie as a nn for the classical Marina). But I must admit I think Sienna works well with Isla.

I would go for Polly, Marnie or Phoebe, all lovely names.
I like Isabelle but wouldn't use a name with same initial.
Darcie is ok but spelling confusion.
Personally not fond of Halle or Sienna.

Sienna - ok
Halle - gorgeous
Phoebe - lovely
Darcie - ok, not keen
Isabelle - bland
Polly - ugh no. Wet, insubstantial and meek.
Marnie - not for me

Halle or Phoebe for me, would probably go for Halle.

Phoebe is the best by far, and Isabelle is fine. The rest are twee, faddish and not classy at all. Sorry.

Sienna - quite like
Halle - ok
Phoebe - love
Darcie - ok, a bit uppity maybe - would spell with a 'y'
Isabelle - pretty but popular, also prefer it spelt Isabel - less frilly
Polly - really nice, underused
Marnie - dislike - sounds like a cross between sarnie/ moany and marmite to me

Polly and Darcey are nice. Don't like the others.

Sienna. It's a very pretty name and sounds nice with Isla.

I like Sienna, Polly and Isabelle best

I think Sienna 'goes' best with Isla, they are both very pretty names.

My thoughts on the others :

Polly or Marnie if you want to be a bit quirky.

Phoebe or Isabel/Isabelle if you want to be more on the classic side.

Halle or Darcie if you want to be more, ahem, downmarket (sorry!)

Thanks everyone. Think we've ruled out Isabelle. Was on the fence anyway so your opinions have helped me decide on that. We have I think 3 favourites on the list now so a definite improvement 😂

Isabel is lovely but it doesn't sound right with Isla and its a bit over used.

Sienna - its ok
Halle - just no
Phoebe - this is my favourite
Darcie - no! Who wants a name with *rse in it?
Polly - lovely but is it an adult name?
Marnie - no. Reminds me if geordie shore.