Help us decide please!

[Nc1468]

I'm almost 28 weeks with our second who is a little girl.

Our son has an ie ending name, think Reggie, Freddie, Alfie, Archie, along those lines.

We really cannot decide between Evie or Alice for our daughter. He suggested Evie and I suggested Alice but now we've completely changed and he loves Alice and I want Evie 🤦🏼‍♀️

We've got quite a common J surname if that helps at all?

Alice! Evie is everywhere lately.

Aslong as your sons name doesn’t start with ‘E’ then I like Evie to go along with the ending- matching but not too similar.
Ie Eddie and Evie is too much but Archie and Evie is nice.

Although Alice is a nice name too.

I prefer Alice.

Alice, Evie is absolutely everywhere and is a bit matchy with your son

Alice.
evie sounds like a pet name, not a proper name.

Elsie?

I think Alice is much nicer 😊 and not as popular

I prefer Evie although this is more popular so depends if that would bother you at all.

Alice is lovely - a classic. Don't go for Evie, there's loads of them! You might also like Ada, Iris or Lucy.

Definitely Alice👍

I am biased towards Evie so would choose that, but Alice was on our short list for dc2.
I don’t know any little Evie’s now, and mine is the only one in her school. There was one other when she was in reception class, in year 5. So quite a long time as the only one. Think it might be declining in popularity now.

Go with Alice it's lovely

Alice is nice and traditional (if fairly popular at the moment), so would be the obvious choice to me.

Evie is nice enough (apart from it's slightly ubiquitous feel). But since you already have a DS name ending in the same sound plus a fairly common surname, I'd personally only use Evie as a nn for the classic Eve (which is surprisingly uncommon - all the other variations are much more popular).

Alice.

Evelyn (similar style to Alice), but use Evie as a nickname?

Alice, then you could use Ali to get your eee sound if you wanted.

Alice

Evie!

I also love suggestions above for Evelyn and Elsie!

I think Evelyn Alice would make a lovely full name combination with Evie for short!

Abigail (Abbie) combines Alice and Evie sounds?

Alice.

Evie, Eve, and all the variations have hugely popular for years.

Alice would be better if you already have an 'ie' ending name. Alice is also a more versatile name.

Alice. So much nicer. Evie is just plain overused now.

Evie is popular but I think it's beautiful and much nicer then Alice. What about Eva or Ava?

Alice!

Alice.

Evie, Eve, and all the variations have hugely popular for years so it's probably peaked.