Finlay or Joshua

[Serendipper]

DH and I can’t decide between the two one of my preference but DH doesn’t like it and the other is his but I’m not sure.

Surname is similar to Davey
One of the names flows better with surname than the other

We would choose a middle name too if anyone has suggestions!

We already have a son called Evan

I like Finlay or Finn

Joshua.
Love Evan.

I prefer Finlay as a name but Joshua flows better

Joshua sounds better with Davey

I have a Fynn. I know a Joshua but he gets Joshy...
Evan and Fynn.

Nice!!
One is Welsh and 1 Irish if that bothers you op!!

Finlay!

I like William, Daniel, Joel or Oscar for middle names with Finlay.

Evan is lovely.

Both BBC are nice but Finlay doesn't scan well with your surname.

Therefore Joshua.

FInlay is gorgeous. I can’t abide Joshua.
However I’d say Joshua Davey goes much better than Finley Davey.

Joshua definitely

Josh.

For some reason I always read Finlay in a brummy accent.

I love Joshua, and it flows better with your surname. Finlay is lovely too though! Tough choice.

Joshua

Joshua is a lovely name.

Finlay is wonderful and goes much better with Evan.
Joshua I find a bit swishy-swashy in the mouth. It doesn't have a nice sound.
Finn is also a much nicer nickname than Josh.

I prefer Joshua, its less 'current' and more timeless. There are lots of little Finn's and Flynn's around at the moment.
I think it works better with your surname too.

I love Finley, slightly different pronunciation.

Joshua.

For some reason I always read Finlay in a brummy accent.
Me too

Joshua.

Both are great names but prefer Finlay

My DS is Finlay. It was a really unusual name when he was born! But just to say that Finlay is the traditional spelling and it’s pronounced the same as Finley - ie not Fin-laaaayy. It’s a gorgeous name and I hope you choose it :)

Joshua is a lovely name.

Both names are nice but Finley Davey sounds a bit sing-songy. Joshua Davey sounds really good. I like Josh as well for a nickname.