Elodie or Ruby?

[dandanphelps3]

My fiancee and I can't decide which name we like more with our dughters Daisy, Indie and Poppy. Can you help us out?

Both are lovely names and work very well with the siblings. I'm torn on this one as I do prefer the sounds of Ruby, but I like that Elodie is much less used. I think I'm edging towards Elodie. However Ruby's sounds are more distinct from your daughters' names while Elodie is similar in sounds to Daisy and Indie, which may be a consideration.

Ruby

Elodie is in my top 5 names. Ruby is a bit more common for me.

Ruby fits with your other daughters as it's two syllables and quite popular.
Elodie is the name I would prefer of the two in other circumstances.

Wouldn't want Elodie to ever be Ellie. I have a Ruby! Remember you have a 'red' name already though!

Ruby

Ruby goes better with your other names but I love Elodie.

I know quite a few Ruby’s so would choose Elodie. So pretty & unusual too.

Ruby goes better with the other names

Elodie sounds a bit too similar to Indie as the last syllable is the same.

Elodie.

Elodie. Gorgeous name!

Ruby fits much better.

Although I prefer Elodie personally.

Elodie

Ruby

Both gorgeous
Sorry not much help

Elodie is nicer, ruby isvery common and makes me think of a promiscuous woman

Really don't like Ruby sorry, love elodie though

Ruby fits better, but Elodie is equally as lovely

I like both, but prefer Ruby with your other names.

I prefer Elodie as a name - but Ruby scans better with your other names. That said, it would soon sound better when said a few times

Ruby as Élodie is far too similar to Indie.
Also better to have a two syllable name as your other girls.

I prefer Ruby as the Elodies I know always get called DeeDee, which I really dislike.

Ruby is more in keeping with the other names.
Elodie is nice in a french accent but a bit nothingy in a UK one, and yet another El- name.

I dislike Elodie (my spellchecker doesn’t like it either, though it does like Eloise) because it sounds like “elodea” which is a weed. Agree with a PP that it sounds a bit meh without a french accent, too.

Ruby is nice, though.