Thoughts on Callie or Aggie?

[Greenlasagne]

They’re not our definitive top two so it’s not one or the other, but I wondered what people thought of both of them? Callie as it is and Agatha shortened to Aggie.

We already have a DD called Nell.

Aggie is horrid.
It’s a very common older woman’s name up here in Scotland and (rightly or not) I associate it with a certain type of woman (a relative of mine included).
I’m sorry, I know it’s your choice,
Callie I like.

Aggie is dreadful. Widely used abbreviation/term for aggressive/violent/angry.

Callie is ok.

Love Nell though.

I absaloutley adore Agatha/Aggie

Not keen on Callie

I really wanted an Agnes, but couldn't deal with Aggie.

Aggie? Awful.

I love Callie (and have a Calvin who we call Cally!)

Aggie is quite normal up here in Scotland - but I prefer Callie. Would it be short for anything?

Callie is okay. However I think Cassie would be a nicer alternative with Nell.
I'm not a fan of Aggie, sorry.

I like both! Also like Agnes..

Aggie is terrible, sorry. Callie is OK but I see it as more of a nickname/shortening e.g. for Caroline.

Love Callie hate Aggie personally

I think I might have heard Aggie being used as slang for aggressive or aggro?

Callie is better than Agatha but not as great as Nell imo

Aggie is an ugly, witchy name.
Callie is not bad but sounds a bit like a dog's name.

Then again I don't like Nell either!

I don't think either of those names flow well with Nell.

Callie is nice but feels like it should be short for something.

Personally strongly Aggie.

*strongly dislike Aggie

What namechange just said. Aggie is so harsh, and a bit of a joke name.

What about Caroline. Then you can sing Sweet Caroline to her.

.. "And when I hurt
Hurting runs off my shoulder
How can I hurt when holding you?"

Sorry I am partial. I was born the year it was in the charts and my middle name is Caroline.

See I really like Aggie, but had a strong suspicion others might feel differently I was right!

Love Callie (regret not calling DD1 this a bit).

I much prefer Callie

Definitely Callie
Aggie is awful

Prefer Agnes to Agatha as full name for Aggie! But I like both Callie and Aggie. Does Nell get called Nellie? As Callie and Nellie might be quite similar if so.

Agatha is OK but I really don't like it shortened to Aggie. It sounds very much like a grumpy old women. Callie is lovely though.

Agnes or Calinda

Never Aggie