Sister for Arabella?

[Enwi]

We have Arabella and all going well, she’ll have a little sister next week. We’re having a really difficult time deciding on something we both like.

Currently we have:
Theodora (I wonder if this looks too masculine)
Ottilie (doesn’t go well with our surname but I love this)
Primrose (possibly too sweet)
Elowen

But none of them feel perfect. I’d love some suggestions please. What would you pair with Arabella Wren?

Claudia.
Penelope
Florence
Madeline
Juliet
Natalia
Anastasia. Alexandria. Angelica. (If them beginning with the same letter doesn't bother you)
Lorelei
Melody
Scarlett
Clemency
Tallulah
Therese
Marina

Madeleine or Penelope.

I love Theodora!

Eleanor
Maria/Marie/Mary/Mariah
Marianna
Penelope
Ariadne
Athena
Josephine
Alina
Ophelia
Amalia
Catherine
Delphine
Daphne
Adela
Emmeline
Evangeline
Francesca
Delia
Florence
Opal
Pearl

Matilda
Emilia
Eloise

Arabella Wren is beautiful

Eden Grace

Erin Felicity

Darcey Primrose

Freya May

Libby Rose

How about the continental version : Teodora?
Or Dorothea?

Clarissa
Jessamine
Miranda
Serena
Jocasta

Nancy

Dorothea.

I love Ottilie. I also love Theodora, don’t think it’s masculine at all.

I’d actually go for Theodora as it’s got the same number of syllables as Arabella, so they go together really nicely.

Evangeline
Madeleine
Genevieve

Meredith Lark
Ursula Jay
Celeste Raven
Elouise Robyn
Linnet Louisa
Rosalind Finch

I like Primrose but it's quite a big name 😃.

Octavia
Ramona
Isadora
Rosemund
Felicity
Phoebe
Caroline
Audrey
Cecily
Honora
Lavender
Thomasina
Verity
Beatrix
Cordelia
Demetria
Poppy/Daisy/Maisie
Romilly
Seraphine
Petra
Violetta
Coraline/Coralie
Florentina
Alice
Doralie
Elodia
Marcellina
Vincentia
Phaedra
Tamsin
Briony
Georgette
Casilde
Sylvie

I'd call her Charlotte Joy. Or Charlotte Robyn if you wanted to continue the bird middle name theme.

If you like Ottilie and it doesn't work with the surname, maybe Octavia as a pp suggested. Or even Olivia. I know it's popular, but I like it with Arabella.

Indie
Olena
Juliette
Evelina
Addelyn
Milena
Saskia
Emery
Leila
Ivy

Also Emilia & Penelope

Cassia.

How about Theadora rather than Theodora we know one and call her Thea for short think it's really pretty

I immediately thought Florence. Also love Thea, I only know one baby called this.

Love Theadora, Primrose and Otillie.

Ophelia
Clementine
Aurora

Theodora goes best with Arabella. It’s not masculine at all. I don’t think the others go.
Valentina
Camilla
Georgina
Cecily
Cecilia
Claudia
Philippa

Theodore is definitely the best from your list. Would she be Thea or Theo in short form though? Magdalen is nice too.

Is Annabelle too similar to Arabella to consider?

I prefer Dorothy to Dorathea and think it sounds great with Arabella.
Not keen on the other names sorry
Arabella and louisa
Arabella and Beatrice
I like previous suggestions of using Robyn or some other nature inspired name for the middle

Thanks so much everyone, these are some fabulous suggestions! Going to speak to DP once he’s finished work. But I feel much more positive with more options. Some of my favourites from those mentioned (have changed some slightly):

Seraphina (this is actually my sister’s name, but I still love it and glad to see someone thinks it goes).
Eloise
Camilla
Clementine
Florence
Alena (don’t like it with the ‘o’ instead of ‘a’)
Emmaline

I like a few others too but are too similar to my name. Will update once I’ve spoken to my DP in the hopes you might all help me with some middle names 🙊