Which one for DD2

[Nubbin]

Sister is Holly -

Summer Ivy Fenella
Summer Bluebell Fenella
Summer Willow Fenella
Summer Fenella Skye

DD1 is the gatekeeper and these are the final choices she has presented us (we are taking Raven and Mooncake with a pinch of salt).

Summer Ivy
Or
Summer Willow

Lovely names

I would ditch Fenella entirely, myself. Then I would pick Summer Ivy (although I like Ivy much more than Summer as a first name)

I dunno. I quite like Mooncake :-)

Although thinking about it you probably don’t want a Holly and an Ivy

Willow

Definitely not Fenella. Anywhere.

Rocking the boat, I like Summer Willow Skye.

Fenella is awful.

Agreed with pp, Summer Willow Skye.
Or choose a different name than Fenella, it doesn't sound good with Summer.

I don't think you can really be called summer followed by any plant name! People will snigger.

Ivy is very much holly's choice and not going to be first! Fenella is a family name - hol got stuck with Ursula....

I quite like Raven.

DD1 should not be picking DD2's name. DD2 did not get to choose DD1's.

Summer Willow

Lose Fenella

If my parents called me Summer because it's what my sister wanted, I'd be well pissed off

Why not choose another name like a holly & stop letting your child dictate to you?

Ditch summer and go with Fenella! It's cool and unusual.

Raven is fine if you don't know the inspiration is teen titans go! DD1 is 10 - if she picked something awful we wouldn't allow it - and she is doing pretty well so far and it is a nice way for her to be engaged. DD2 will know we all chose it together.

Now how to convince DH we can find another Scottish name in the family tree that isn't Fenella.

My sister picked my middle name when I was born, everyone though5 it was lovely. Turns out she only picked it as she liked the titanic movie

Fenella is my favourite by far . I’d put that first.

Fenella is good.

Fenella is great! Summer and Holly is a weird combo, like a season theme gone wonkey.

Fenella Ivy

I love Fenella. Really different. Its my favourite on your list.

TBH Fenella sounds like a vaginal cream (sorry) and Summer will be very dated in a few years time. Also what would be the shortened variation be? Would she be called Sum by her friends?

Summer Ivy Fenella.

Fenella Skye sounds too much like Vanilla Sky.

Bluebell is a real guilty pleasure name of mine - but with Summer it’s a bit too floral even for me.

Really dislike Fenella.

Your daughter shouldn't even be having a say in the name. She will have the opportunity to choose a name for her own child when she's old enough. This is your child, you decide the name.

It's nice to involve the older child, but perhaps limit it to the middle name choice?

Fen is a nice nn. Sum isn't.