Girls names? Help!

[HolyMayonnaise]

Hello MN!

We would be grateful for your help, opinions and alternative suggestions to our current girls list:

Connie (I really love Constance as a FN)
Bonnie
Polly

We love the name Anna also but we can't use it due to it being used by a family member.

Thank you 😘

I really like Connie, Polly is ok, bonnie belongs on a dog.

I really like Bonnie!

Lottie
Betty
Penny

Really love all three names you’ve listed!

Other names:

Margot
Willa
Imoge.n
Sadie
Edith / Edie
Margaret /Maggie
Clementine/ Clemmie
Roxanne/Roxanna/Rosanne
Pearl
Delilah
Ottilie /Ottie
Cora
Eliza
River
Winter
Jemima
Holly (alternative to Polly?)
Cleo
Mabel
Peggy
Martha

Bonnie is the nicest. Polly is okay. It seems you like the old fashioned scullery maid names!

You could merge and have Pollyanna.

Constance is a bit stale/twee, imo it's not very pretty and it would be a bit of a gamble as to whether she would like it when shes older.

How about:
Rosa
Faith
Alice
Primrose

Love Constance with or without the Connie.
Not keen on the other two as they are embedded as animal names in my mind!

If you like the ie/y sound try

Winifred nn Winnie
Holly
Ellie
Josie
Halle

Polly

Other suggestions.
Tilly.
Lindy.
Christie.
Dolly
Susie.
Dottie.
Misty.
Tansy.
Posy
Edie
Nori
Patsy.
Molly
Kiki
Emmie
Indie
Katie
Trixie

I love Bonnie

Love Connie and Polly. Hate Bonnie.

Tara is lovely

Polly is very nice. Dislike the others I'm afraid.

I like Polly and Connie.

I like Connie.

Peggy
Audrey
Daphne
Susie
Dorothy
Betty
Annie

Bonnie is horrid. I like Constance. I’m not wild on Connie, though. Polly is nice and is growing on me.

I agree with every word daisypond said.

Bonnie isn't nice as a name and it's an adjective anyway so, to me, it's like calling your DC Tall or Green. waits for someone to come along and list a load of common adjective-names

I like Polly and Constance. Not a huge fan of Connie but it's pleasant enough. I'd probably go for Polly.

All are nice nicknames.

This is pretty much much name list!

Connie has been my fave since the get go, Anna is a close second. I’m not mega keen on Constance though and prefer ‘nicknames’ to have a ‘proper name’ for the BC

My sister is called Connie and I think it’s such a pretty name. I’ve never met another either. I like Polly. Not keen on Bonnie at all - I think of as a dogs name.

Constance with nn Connie is great, Connie is very pretty but good to have an elegant more serious alternative if she fancies it when growing up. I agree with PPs suggestion of Clementine nn Clemmie as an option?
Polly I think is a bit too nursery rhyme for me. Bonnie is nice but just makes me think of Bonny as an adjective rather than a name and I would worry that being called ‘Pretty’ or ‘lovely’ or however we translate it would be a heavy name to carry, especially when at self conscious teen age potentially... but I overthink things!

Polly is lovely
Connie (Constance) in nice
Bonnie is too nicknamey and can be an euphemism for chubby

Constance is one of my dd’s middle names and I quite often wish I’d used it as a first name.

I love Connie, but I'm not overly keen on Polly or Bonnie.

I don't like any of your names, sorry. They sound like names for a doll rather than a person. Bonnie is by far the worst.

If you like Anna but can't use it, consider these:
Anya
Annabelle
Anastasia
Arianna
Or any other name that ends in -anna, such as Lianna, Rhianna, Rosanna etc.