Which one of these names......

[oldmahubbard]

Other suggestions welcome

Octavius
Barnaby
Crispin

Digby
Wilfred
Caspian
Benedict

Digby, Barnaby or Benedict.

Other suggestions -
Lysander
Sebastien
Julian
Montgomery
Rupert
Montague
Josiah
Augustus
Peregrine

Wilfred or Barnaby.

Caspin

Digby makes me think of Rigby which makes me think of Rising Damp.

I like really like Wilfred and like Caspian too.

If you like Benedict, how about Dominic?

Barnaby is ok but the only one I've known wasn't very well behaved. He was known as Barney, and as Barnaby when being naughty.

I don't like Crispin. Makes me think of crisps. Octavius is very Jacob Rees Mogg as someone else said.

My favourites are Caspian and Benedict. I also like Caspar and Quentin.

I don't like Wilfred or Digby at all.

I agree with a pp that they sound a bit wet. Wilfred is the only one I don’t mind.

I LOVE Barnaby

Suggestions in a similar vein...

Barnabas
Caspar
Lucian
Florian
Rufus
Isidore
Jolyon
Joscelin
Tristram
Aubrey
Orlando
Inigo
Horatio
Clement
Rollo
Conrad

Wilfred 😍

Octavius - awful. Sounds like a superhero baddie.
Barnaby- Not bad.
Crispin - A picture a charred, burnt body.
Digby - Dog.
Wilfred - Not bad.
Caspian - - wet.
Benedict - not bad.

Did you decide @oldmahubbard

Octavius is awful! I'd think you were a Rees-Mogg wannabe.
Barnaby is LOVELY.
Crispin seems like a bit of a joke name and was used in a film - I can't for the life of me remember which film -as the name of someone really wet and weedy and that's what I think of when I hear it.
Digby - cool
Wilfred - cool but getting pretty popular
Caspian - amazing!
Benedict - also cool

Wilfred is too popular for your tastes I think.

Digby is cool, I know of one. I also really like Barnaby.

Crispin is awful, Octavius too much. Caspian and Benedict are alright.