Shortlist for each

[yestonodressyet]

Boys
Theodore - worried it's overused now
Monty - DH unsure as 'we're not posh'
Winston - both like but not sure we love it

Girls
Clementine
Matilda

Surname is double barrelled with different sounds so doesn't have to go with that really

Boys
Theodore - thoroughly dislike, overused. Theo is overused but better
Monty - a bit too nicknamey
Winston - love it

Girls
Clementine - too fruity
Matilda - overused

I love Winston and Clementine! Two of my favourite names.

How about;
Caspian
Nathan
Elijah

Ingrid
Alessia
Juniper

Theodore - overused especially Theo
Monty - too nicknamey
Winston - love it - great strong and cool!

Clementine - love it.
Matilda - overused and dull

Love Winston and Clementine!

Theodore and Matilda are indeed a little dull, from being overused.

Love Clementine and Matilda
Matilda much rarer than it used to be and Clementine getting more popular

Don’t like Monty. I promise I never usually say this but I really see it as dogs name

Theodore - nice
Monty - no, it's a diminutive of Montgomery or Montague
Winston - reminds me of Michael Whitehall's doll...

Clementine - nice
Matilda - nice

I love Theodore

Other ideas:
Otis
Ellis
Christopher or Kit
Barnaby
Rafferty nn Raffy
Miles
Eric
Eli
Chester
Cole
Caleb

If you like Winston how about Wilfred? Nn Wilf

Your girl names aren't my cup of tea, sorry.

I love Theodore. Winston is also really good. My nephew is Montague (Monty) and let's just say it raised a few eyebrows when they announced the name. There was a lot of 'oh that's rather posh!'. It does sound very public school boy to me.

I like pp suggestion of Wilfred (Wilf) too.

Monty and Clementine are fab! Clementine has been my favourite for years, so sad I didn’t get to use it.

Theodore - lovely
Monty - good, but prefer Montgomery with Monty as nn
Winston - don’t partupicularlynlike

Clematine - love
Matilda. - ok

Other suggestions
Donovan (Donny
Sebastian
Christopher

Magdalene
Juliette
Evelyn
Olivia

Clementine is my girls name of choice. I love Matilda too but I think it’s quite common.

I only like Winston from your boys list.

Love Clementine and Matilda, Theo is nice, know a nice little Monty, think it's OK. Dislike Winston.

Sorry should have said Monty would have Montgomery on the birth certificate.
As PPs have suggested I love wilf(red) snd really pushes for it for DS1 but DH was a firm no on using it!

I really don't like Winston but love Winnie for a girl!
Not a fan of Clementine, Matilda (Tilly or Matty is lovely).
I do like Theo and taught a lovely Monty

I know someone (just remembered) who has called their DD Wilhelmina - Billie or Mina as a NN and I love the nn

Love Theodore and Matilda - if you like it Go for it! You’ll regret not using a name just because it’s popular, give it a few years and it probably won’t be.

LOVE Montgomery nn Monty. Much better than Winston (sounds kind of fusty) and Theodore (it's very nice but quite common).

Matilda is a bit overdone and clunky for me. Love Clementine, unsure about Clemmy nn but Clementine is really lovely.

Theodore - I really like it but it does seem popular
Monty - I like and don't think it sounds any more 'posh' than all the other names in your list!
Winston - makes me think of a gorilla?!
Clementine - too frilly for my taste
Matilda - I like it and LOVE nn Tilly

Theodore - it's overused now.
Monty - weird.
Winston - awful. Reminds me of a jowly Churchill.

Clementine - 'Clem' is such an ugly sound. Like slang for genitals.
Matilda - pretty.

Monty is just awful, sorry! And it's becoming more popular. I now know 3!
I ADORE Clementine.

Love Winston and Clementine!

Theodore and Clementine are lovely names.