Matilda, Annabelle, Beatrice and ???

[itmsylifeitsnowornever]

I'm pregnant with girl number 4.

Older girls are Matilda, Annabelle and Beatrice. They go by Maddie, Annie and Trixie. Maddie was originally Mattie but somehow she became Maddie, I know it's not a traditional nickname for Matilda.

We had picked Eleanor and were working on middle names. However, my cousin had her daughter this morning and called her an almost identical name, so we are back to the drawing board.

Our "Rules" are:
3 syllables
Doesn't start with M, A or B (no repeat initials)
Can be shortened.

What do you suggest?

Eloise

Jennifer, Louisa, Claudia, Francesca, Susannah

If Beatrice is Trixie does that rule T names out under the no repeat letters rule?

Harriet.

Ottilie
Violet

Imogen

Gwendoline

Juliet or Harriet sound lovely with the other names

Scarlett (I know 2 syllables but does sound nice with the others!), could nn lottie

Emmeline, Genevieve, Philippa

Josephine

For Tabitha you could also use Tibby (too close to Trixie?), Beth, Bethie. Ettie and Hetty are other options for Harriet.

These are probably already mentioned but:
Camilla/Milly
Cressida/ Cressy
Josephine/Posy
Genevieve/Vivi or Evie
Eugenie/Genie
Estella/Essie, Estie, Ellie
Dorothy/Dolly, Dodie, Dottie
Rosamund/Rosie, Romy
Lucinda/Lucy, Lucie
Susannah/Suky, Susy
Eponine/Eppie, Penny

Josephine

Imogen or Rosalind

Emmeline- Emmy
Harriet- Hattie
Josephine- Josie
Rebecca- Becky
Evelyn- Evie

Emmeline

Rosemary
Fenella
Jessamine
Leonore
Finola
Eudora
Vanessa
Eliza
Keziah

I think you need whatever makes the nn Nell as that would work so well - Maddie, Annie, Trixie & Nell. So probably Helena nn Nell (as Eleanor is out).

Jessica
Harriet
Louisa
Imogen
Isabel

Elfrida nn. Elfie
Tabitha nn. Tabbie
Elizabeth nn. Lizzie
I know you got an Annie but i do like:
Agatha nn. Taggie
Artemis nn. Misty

Imogen (immy imo gen)
Margaret (Maggie)
Clementine (clemmie)
Roxanne /Roxanna (Roxy)

Delilah
Ottilie (Ottie)

Tabitha
Verity
Francesca
Genevieve
Violet
Clementine
Elodie
Vivienne
Harriett

I know a lovely Jemima and childhood friends call her Mimi.

My suggestions:
Harriet (Hattie)
Camilla (Millie)
Lydia (Lydi)

4 syllables as opposed to 3:
Persephone (Sephy)
Penelope (Penny)
Ophelia (Lia)

@Whatsyourflava Are you MOD?

Evalina would go with your existing name choices. Alse, the nickname can be Eva or Evie and I think it's quite a classy name.

Matilda, Annabelle, Beatrice & Evalina