Narrow down long list

[McShakey]

I posted before and got lots of suggestions, I’ve added a few that me and DH thought of ourselves. I know a lot of names are nicknames, but we won’t be putting the longer version on the birth certificate as that’s just personal preference and we don’t see the point in having a name on the birth certificate that we never intend on using (I have a nickname name and that’s never held me back).

Mary
Ada
Pearl
Winnie
Enid
Elsie
Daisy
Edie
Nellie
Opal
Nancy
Tilly
Dottie

Our last name starts in S and is a syllable long. What name would be your favourite? And any middle name suggestions?

I like Edie a lot. Would pair it with Wren as a middle name x

Pearl Smith
Opal Smith
Daisy Smith
Enid Smith

My favourite is Opal from your list, by quite a margin.

I know you didn't say it was Smith.

I like Ada (prefer Ida though), Pearl, Daisy and Edie (prefer Edith).

Pearl is my fave.

Mary
Pearl
Winnie

Love these!

Nancy is also nice, but less special than these imo.

I like Edie and would use Violet as a middle name.

Ada Elsie and Nellie are my faves!

I like all three of the above with Rose!

Daisy or Nancy would both go well with a short surname beginning with S. Not keen on Winnie - it's the sound a horse makes!

Mary - yes
Ada - no
Pearl - no
Winnie - yes
Enid - not sure
Elsie - no
Daisy - ok
Edie - not sure
Nellie - no. Not on your...
Opal - Vauxhall. No
Nancy - yes
Tilly -- not sure
Dottie - yes

Mary's my favourite but Dottie and Winnie are charming

Nancy.

Winnie.
Enid
Daisy
Mary
Tillie
Dottie

Elsie
Daisy
Edie

I like Daisy and Nancy best

Mary - an old fashioned name and not one that has now become fashionable - really don’t like it.

Ada - lovely

Pearl - lovely

Winnie - the Pooh
Enid - please no

Elsie - nice

Daisy - very overused but it’s fine. Nothing special.

Edie - lovely

Nellie - the elephant

Opal - nice (ish)

Nancy - fine, bit boring

Tilly - very cutsie but ok if that’s your style. Nice if nn for Matilda

Dottie - potential teasing if she has spots growing up.

Esie is my favourite

I like Edie & Mary.

I don't like any of the others.

We’ve narrowed it down to Ada and Edie

Edie is lovely

I think we will go with Edie. Any middle name suggestions?

I like Elsie, Edie and Daisy best. Not sure on middle names though

Edie Pearl
Edie Alice
Edie Grace

Edie Wren
Edie Marie
Edie Opal
Edie Nancy
Edie Summer
Edie Honey
Edie Margot
Edie Elizabeth
Edie Chloe
Edie Erin
Edie Jade
Edie Claire
Edie Primrose

Family names that could be used for middle names are:

Marguerite
Elizabeth
Hope
Lynette
Heather
Ann

I’d probably have two middle names, one that we like and then one family name

Edie
Ada
Dotty

Not sure how to fit these with the middle names

Edie Marguerite followed by a single syllable S surname is lovely!!