Middle name for boy twin

[boodles101]

I'm having boy/girl twins and we can't settle on a middle name for the boy. Me and DH have very different opinions on names, I like plain traditional and he likes different, out there, movie/TV style names.
We already have a son called Will Hendricks P.

Girl twin will be Erin Rose P
Boy will be Alex ...... P

Our surname is quite unusual and people find it hard to say/pronounce so an easy first name is what we've gone with.
If I had my way it would be Alex James but clearly I'm not getting my way.

Any suggestions that you think could go with Alex and please both of us?

Jude
Rory
Jonah
Luca

Alexander Hunter P
Alexander Jamison P
Alexander Ignatius P
Alexander Saul P

It's a middle name, for all it'll be used you could call him Alexander SponsoredbyCbeebies P.

James is lovely

You could go classic but unusual:
Alex Gideon P.
Alex Benedict P.
Alex Quentin P.
Alex Reuben P.

Or you could go male flower name to link with Rose:
Alex Bud P.
Alex Florian P.
Alex Rowan P.

I like James too, it flows well with Alex.

Alex George
Alex Finn

I love Jude but DH isn't keen.
I'll show him the classic/unusual names later and see what he thinks.

Divgirl2 I know it'll be hardly used which is why I stupidly gave DH the option to chose it but the names he's picking are just truly awful! His 2 favourites are Ragnar and Ivar biggun

My husband wanted to call our little boy Thomas Rex - T. rex for short not awful but not my but we did Thomas jack after his grandfather who passed ... any grandads you could name the baby after?

Alex Tate
Alex Micah
Alex Blake
Alex Brody

No grandads to name after as both of us had disappearing fathers.

Ooo I quite like Alex Tate, I'll put that to DH thanks

Ivo is maybe a bit cooler than Ivar?

Rafe
Ranulph
Blake
Sawyer

Peter

Rose

Axel Rose

Our surname ends in an O sound, so think Ivo would be too much. That goes for all sorts of names like Leo, Theo etc.

I love Rafe too, was on my list for first name but again DH not keen.

Alex Ivan

Or how about a traditional sounding name but with an unusual quirky spelling?
I normally pity children with weirdly spelt names, but if it’s a middle name then the child won’t have to spell it out to people all the time and very few people actually know a child’s middle name.

Alex Remy
Alex Torin
Alex Morgan
Alex Brodie
Alex Rocco
Alex Bryson
Alex Carter
Alex Lincoln
Alex Hudson
Alex Quinn
Alex Colby
Alex Luca
Alex Marcus
Alex Vincent

Alex Jensen

Alex James flows nicely and you have.the option on AJ as a nickname. I also liked to idea of Tate. Alex Christian (AC) sounds nice too.

Hunter
Quinn
Micah
Kier
Lux
Eden
Grayson
Gideon
Carter
Jackson
Wilson
Asher
Ashton
Riley
Cole
Kit
Leigh
Tate
Nate
Sean
Orion
Nova
Rae
Stanley
Rex
Rufus
Storm
Jett
Vincent
Vernon
Asher
Emmett
Brent
Bradley
Chase
Dexter
Devon

John is classic and underused

What about Ellis

Quinn is a good shout cos we originally had that down as a unisex first name when we didn't know what we were having so I know he likes it!