Caitlin or Scarlett combo

[Kathryn3C]

Opinions pls, our two favourite girl names are Caitlin or Scarlett but don't know if we can use them together, if they flow right.
Scarlett Caitlin or
Caitlin Scarlett
Which is better or if can't use both together then other middle name suggestions for either? Thanks.

Caitlin Scarlet sounds fine together although not a huge fan of Scarlet - what about Caitlin Juliet ?

I love Scarlett, they sound fine together either way round. I think Scarlett is so pretty.

Scarlett hands down.

It'll be nice to see Caitlin make a come back. I've never been a fan of Scarlett.
Caitlin Mary
Caitlin Olivia
Caitlin Georgina
Caitlin Aurora
Caitlin Martha
Caitlin Rose
Caitlin Amber
Caitlin Daisy
Caitlin Abigail
Caitlin Brooke
Caitlin Naomi
Caitlin Emilia

I have a Caitlin Mary so I'm biased towards that

I have a Caitlin Mary too. :)
Caitlin Scarlett is nice- pretty sure Scarlett O'Hara was a Katie Scarlett.

Caitlin Alexandra
Caitlin Isabella
Caitlin Rosabelle
Caitlin Victoria
Caitlin Nevaeh
Caitlin Josephine.
Caitlin Melody

If you do go for Scarlett.
Scarlett Grace
Scarlett Evangeline
Scarlett Louisa
Scarlett Olivia
Scarlett Blythe
Scarlett Aurora
Scarlett Lucinda
Scarlett May
Scarlett Renée
Scarlett Ava
Scarlett Maria

Caitlin/Scarlett Elizabeth.

How would you pronounce Caitlin? The correct Irish way or the incorrect English way?

What Heratnumber7 said ^^

I hate Caitlyn. Scarlett is lovely!

Scarlett Caitlyn is pretty if you use the correct pronunciation. If you were using the American pronunciation (Kate-lynn) it sounds hideous.

The American mispronunciation of a perfectly nice Irish name is just awful, in the realm of 'Chevonne' or 'Neev'. Cáitlín, properly pronounced and spelled, is nice.

Scarlett Caitlin. (Though it sounds fine either way).

I hate Caitlin. Never met a nice one

Hate Caitlyn love Scarlett. Don't like Scarlett Caitlyn, Caitlyn Scarlett sounds better

Caitlin Scarlett is too much Gone With The Wind for me - Katie Scarlett. If you want to use both, put Scarlett first.

"The American mispronunciation of a perfectly nice Irish name is just awful, in the realm of 'Chevonne' or 'Neev'. Cáitlín, properly pronounced and spelled, is nice."

I'd genuinely be interested to hear what the correct pronunciations of Caitlin, Siobhan and Niamh are? I'm not American, but I would pronounce them Kate-Lyn, Chevonne (I work with one who pronounces it like that) and Neev as you describe. What should they be?

Looks like captain Scarlett so it's a no from me

Kathleen is how Caitlyn is pronounced i think.

@flowery it' like cotch-leen. Your other pronouncuations are correct

Sort of half way between Kathleen and Cotchleen. Difficult to describe in English.

Thanks for replies. I think I am leaning towards Scarlett Caitlin

I prefer Caitlin. For me scarlett is very severe and Caitlin is a much nicer name, also I don't think it's very common nowadays.