Imogen or Sienna?

[Azuresea]

Posted a few days back and narrowing choices.
So which would you choose?
Thank you.

Both are lovely. I personally prefer Imogen

Imogen

hmm not really a fan of either but if I had to pick maybe Sienna. for some reason Imogen reminds me of a medicine?!

Some people have said before that Imogen is down market or horrible and frumpy.
Personally I can't see this but am I missing something?!

I don't think Imogen is down-market. It sounds ugly and frumpy to me, yes.

Sienna is prettier but is probably considered more down market by some people.

They are very different to each other.

Imogen.

Imogen!

The rough girls with funny eyebrows who get excluded at dds school are usually named sienna. Make of that what you will

Siena, not Sienna. My daughter is 26 and named Siena after the city in Italy. At that stage, it was a very unusual name. In fact I knew none.

Siena is a beautiful name

Imogen is more classic Sienna is more fashionable but both are great names

Sienna is a lovely name.

Sienna. I just don’t like Imogen at all for some reason but Mumsnet loves it

Imogen.
It feels rather "market-less", actually! Hard to pinpoint. Whereas Sienna conjures a very clear, although undoubtedly unfair, mental image- at least for me!

I like both but I think I prefer sienna. Although if youd have asked me last week or next week I might be inclined to say imogen!

I have an Imogen. DH. Hose her name and I really wasn't keen but it has grown on me and I now love it. We always get complimented on her name and how pretty it is

Imogen reminds me of Imagine.. I like both

Imogen 💕

Imogen is gorgeous and timeless. I also think sienna as faddy.