Twin girls Mataya and ??

[LifesMiracles19]

We have two boys, Malachi and Micaiah

We have a still born daughter named Mackenzie.

Our baby #1 will be Mataya

For her sister...
Mylia (my-lee-uh) ) (my favourite)
Marissa
Marina
Morgana
Modesta
Malaysia

I like Marissa.

Martina?
Mariana?

Mavaiyah, Marianna would be my choices.

I like Mylia the best from your list.

Another vote for Mylia. Still the linking 'M' theme but different enough from Mataya to make it less likely that other people, say in a school setting, will get their names mixed up - even more important if they look very much like each other.

I like Morgana and Marissa.

Malika

Mylia from your list, also like

Milana
Monique

Is the middle syllable of Mataya pronounced like ‘eye’ or ‘hay’?

I'm sorry about your stillborn daughter.

Do they really have to have M names? Siblings with similar names is one thing (not my taste, but fine if you like that kind of thing). But twins, being in the same school year, are very prone to getting mixed up or treated as a unit, even with fraternal twins let alone identical twins. Most twins, when asked about this kind of thing, are pretty adamant that it is better for twins to be given names that do not begin with the same letter (or that rhyme), in order to reduce these kinds of social difficulties.

Maia - or is that too close to Mataya?

Malia.
Margetta
Marguerita.
Maud - she could be nicknamed Maudie.
Michaela.

Mahalia

I agree with the above poster about having all the same intials , especially twins. It's not to my taste at all, I'd personally choose different initials .

But of your list I like Marissa best

Marina. Beautiful name!

Marina!

Marissa or Marina.

Like Marisa, what about Melissa

I prefer the Mattea spelling to Mataya. Mattea and Marina would be lovely.

Am I right in assuming you’re a Jewish family?

I’d go with a name that doesn’t end in -a. It’s too much.

Having said that, I quite like Maura, so....

Marissa

Aren’t that all a mouthful. I really like Marrisa. My favourite M names are Malin & Myer though

Why all the M's? Try Matalan!!

Marina goes well because it’s sound complements the sound of Mataya, wiiout sounding too similar

Marina.

Marlita