Girls name help!

[Pineapples19]

Its driving me mad that we can't agree on a name, my favourites are:
Otillie (oh says no)
Matilda (oh says no)
Violet (hate the thought of it being shortened to Vi)
Mabel (sounds odd with our surname)

His favourites are:
Harper
Imogen

Any suggestions gratefully received!

Otillie - I'm honestly not sure how I would pronounce this, it's honestly a little intimidating looking where you have to think twice before saying it outloud.
Matilda - Cute, but don't love it
Violet - I like it and I actually love the nn V. You could also use lettie as a nn.
Mabel - Cute, pretty, simple.

His favourites are:
Harper - Dislike, just sounds harsh.
Imogen - I find this hard to pronounce, so no for me.

Love Otilllie!
Talulah, Delilah, Penelope, Florence, Annabelle, Peony, Alice, Primrose, Rosanna, Bridget, Margot

Georgina
Gracie/Grace
Ruth
Charity
Hattie (Harriet)
Margaret
Marianne
Alice
Florence
Mary
Felicity
Lydia
Aurora

Love all of them except wouldn't use Harper as it's a bit "of the moment" and worried it would date badly.

How about Genevieve, Beatrice, Eliza, Olive, Scarlett, Margot, Martha, Flora, Eleanore, Lorelei, Juliet, Jemima, Tabitha?

Also, Violet can be shortened to Lettie which I think is lovely.

Rosalie
Scarlett
Sienna
Darcy
Martha
Sophie
Lydia

Astrid
Rosa
Georgia
Esme
Juno

Ottilie, it’s my daughters middle name DH wouldn’t let it be a first!

Imogen would be my favourite from your list.

Saffron
Romilly
Elsie
Freya
Carys
Darcy
Emmeline
Adaline
Lorna
Clara
Kiera
Lauren
Estelle
Lois
Bryony
Phoebe
Francesca
Marina
Rosina
Lara
Lori
Verity
Madeline
Marissa
Leah
Soreya
Camilla
Cecilia
Isobel
Jasmine
Megan
Lottie (Charlotte)
Eliza
Brooke

Imogen is great and my clear favourite from your lists. I would cross off Harper and cross off Mabel if it doesn't work with surname. I like both Violet (call her Letty if you need a nn) and Matilda.

Verity
Catherine
Lillian
Harriet
Henrietta
Esther
Hazel
Rosanna
Eliza
Madeleine
Meredith
Alexandra
Charlotte
Lucia
Claudia
Christabel
Annabelle
Isobel
Nancy
Romana
Lilia
Clara
Clare
Francesca
Emma
Emilia
Joanna
Helena
Georgina
Victoria

I'd cross ottilie and matilda off straight away if you oh doesn't like them!

Violet is quite a short name anyway so may not get shortened, the two I know are always Violet.

I like imogen from your ohs list - how do you feel about it?

Harper is really not to my taste and agree with pp that it will date.

I have a Violet and no one has ever called her Vi. Her nickname is simply V. Or Little Pickle 😉

Marina
Greta
Anna
Louisa
Zara
Megan
Nina
Stella
Talia
Cara
Juliet
Opal
Pearl
Rowan
Alice
Faye

Love Violet and Imogen. Violet can be Lettie.

I really wouldn’t name a kid after VB’s dd. I’d steer clear of names with any celeb association. Plus it will date horribly.

There are so many little girls called Matilda these days and Ottile. I’m sure in years to come they will be the “Leanne” of today.

I love Imogen and Mabel
Harper's becoming more popular so depends if that bothers you or not

Hazel
Ivy
Willow
Alana
Bethany
Iona
Saskia
Madeleine
Natalia
Maisie
Sadie

You have all been so helpful, we have lots of names to discuss now, pleased to hear Violet isn't automatically shortened to Vi, I wouldn't feel the need to shorten it myself but sometimes people take it upon themselves to!
I do like Imogen, I'm just not sure its "the one".
I like Margot, Eliza and a few others you have suggested, will see what the OH says! Thank you.