Which boy's name?

[dayonara]

Trying to choose between the following. We like quite traditional names, not bothered about popularity but would prefer something not too trendy.

William
Benjamin
Samuel
James
Gabriel
Theodore (nickname would be Theo)
Elias

Love all of them! Not helpful, I know.

I’ve always been partial to Gabriel. Elias is nice too.

James

Theodore & James are my favourite.

I'm also very fond of Benjamin & Samuel. Elias is nice too.

Samuel or Gabriel