A sister for...

[Lifeaback]

DD4 is on the way! Her sisters are Edith (nn edie) grace (gets Gracie as a nn) Matilda (gets tilda/tilds as a nn). On the list at the minute are-

Florence
Lana
Beatrice (worried about how common it is though, especially as already have Matilda which is very popular)
Poppy (this is on the list because goes really nicely with our surname but again worried about it being too common)
Talitha (pretty name but think it might be too much with tilda as a nn for dd3)

I love the names Ophelia and Genevieve but not sure if they're too pretentious and just can't quite imagine Ophelia fitting a baby. Any other suggestions/thoughts on our current list would be great! With all the other girls Ive been dead set on a name instantly so this is quite strange for me

I actually think that Genevieve (vivie) would work beautifully.

It's cute on a little one and suitable for an adult.

Eleanor- Ellie/Elle
Beatrix- Trixie/Trix/Bea
Alice
Felicity- Flick/Fliss/Fi

I favour Alice myself

Florence is nicest of your list, with Lana a close second.

I prefer Tabitha to Talitha.

How about Nina?

I like Poppy the best, from your list, I don't know any !
It goes well with your other names, Edie, Gracie, Tilda and Poppy.

I like Poppy, and prefer Tabitha to Talitha. Do you like Clementine, Rosalie, Felicity or Iris?

I love Genevieve nn- Gen, Genny, Vie, Vieve.

Your DDs have lovely names!
Genevieve is cute. Beatrice /Florence/Poppy have been popular around here lately.
How about -
Judy
Chloe
Anne
Clara
Jana
Bluebell
Meadow

Florence is more popular than Matilda and Beatrice.

Beatrix
Iris
Mabel
Clara

I think Genevieve goes best. Such a pretty name too!

Leaning slightly more towards Genevieve as it's got such a positive response! Didn't even think of Vivi as a nickname but really like it now

I love Florence and Beatrice! I don't think Beatrice is very common, I've just checked out the 2017 most popular baby names in uk and Beatrice doesn't even appear in the top 100. Florence is much more popular -it ranks #39. I wouldn't worry about popularity though -they are both gorgeous names!

I like Genevieve too, very classy!

Lana, Beatrice, Ophelia and Genevieve are all lovely :) I like your other daughters names too, good taste!

Can’t stand Genevieve and Genny is such a boring name.

Really like Beatrice and Talitha - but I can see why you’d think the latter was too similar to Matilda.

Beatrice is nowhere near as popular as Grace and Matilda.

I love Beatrice nn Bea. Love it love it love it!

Rosalind, Rosie.
Dorothea, Dorrie.
Charlotte, Lottie.

Don't like Genevieve or Ophelia.
I suggest Lottie short for Charlotte.

I like Florence, Beatrice and Poppy, though I'm not sure Poppy goes with your other DDs' names. I really dislike Ophelia. It's a name you can't win with. It either makes you look pretentious - showing off that you've read your Shakespeare - or ignorant - you don't know Ophelia's dreadful story. I like Genevieve. But are you happy to have two daughters with the same initial? If you like Vivi, would Vivian/Vivienne/Vita be any good?

Penelope
Nancy
Cleopatra

I was going to suggest Vivienne too.
I thought Genevieve was shortened to Evie, which is pretty.

Florence and Beatrice go well with your other DDs names.

What beautiful names, you have great taste.

Harriet
Alberta
Constance
Francesca

I love Lana, Talitha and Genevieve (though I agree Tilda is too close if DD4 were to end up as Tally)

Less keen on Florence, Poppy, Beatrice and Ophelia but they're all nice names.

Other ideas - Edie, Gracie, Tilda and ...
Annabelle (Annie/Anna)
Arabella (Bella)
Cassandra (Cassie/Cass)
Camilla (Milla)
Fenella (Nella/Nell)
Henrietta (Hetty)
Imogen (Immy)
Joanna (Jo)
Jessica (Jess/Jessie)
Juliette (Etta)
Katherine (Katie/Kitty)
Madeleine (Maddie)
Philippa (Pippa)
Sophia

Thank you all for the positive responses and other suggestions! Charlotte nn Lottie is on the list now along with pippa, and think Florence and poppy have been ruled out

I love Talitha, but agree it’s too close to Tilda.

Genevieve is nice. I know one who never shortens it.

How about Kitty or Saskia?

Beatrice is nicest and works best imo.