Subset, are these too similar?

[alwaysmuddy]

We have an Ottilie Annabel. If the next one (due in 2 weeks!) Is a girl then we are stuck for a name.
We like Romilly Florence. Are ottilie and romilly too similar for sisters?

P.s we shorten ottilie to ottie (never Tilly). I anticipate romilly would be Ro or Romy (never Milly) so unlikely to end up with both a Tilly and a Milly!!

Does Ottilie have a nickname? And will you give Romily a nickname?
I think if they are going to be called Ottilie and Romilly all the time it might be a bit too similar
Tilly(Ottilie) and Milly (Romilly) I think would also be too similar

They are fine, they are similar in style but not in sound & go very well together.

X post, in that case I dont think they are too similar

I think they're fine together. However I wouldn't ruin a beautiful name like Romilly with a nn. There are some names I don't think should be shortnend Romilly being one of them. Until late they can decide for themselves, obviously

I love them both but think hey are too similar. I wouldn't personally go for these two together. Sorry!

What about Florence for a first name?

Romilly makes me think of a war general or something. If you're going for Ro how about Rowena or Rowella. For Romy how about Rosemary?

I’d get them tangled and end up shouting Rottily and Ommily. Too similar.

Lovely names

Very nice !

I think they’re too sing-songy together. I’m also not keen on Romilly.

Too close for me as well.

I thought Romy was a name in its own right; could you choose it instead?